Directions (Qs. 1–5): Read the following statements carefully and answer the questions which follow.
1. The ministry of sports has been advised by a committee to take the highest award in the field of sports back from two players who were allegedly involved in match fixing.
Which of the following statements would weaken the argument put forward by the committee to the sports ministry? (IBPS PO 2013)
(a) A good conduct in the past and a lack of evidence against the players make the case against them very weak.
(b) The ministry of sports has never declined the recommendations made by the committee earlier.
(c) Taking the award back from the players would set a good example to other players for avoiding such actions in the future.
(d) There have been past cases where the award had to be taken back from the players owing to some misconduct later on.
(e) The committee is constituted of some of the most respected from the fields of sports and politics.
Answer: (a)
Explanation: The committee has advised the sports ministry to take back the highest award from two players because they were allegedly involved in match-fixing.
To weaken this argument, we need a statement that casts doubt on the reason or justification for taking the award back.
Let’s check each option:
(a) A good conduct in the past and a lack of evidence against the players make the case against them very weak.
This directly weakens the committee’s recommendation because it says:
- The players have a good past record
- There is no strong evidence of wrongdoing
If there is no solid proof, the justification for withdrawing the award becomes weak and doubtful.
So this weakens the argument the most.
(b) The ministry of sports has never declined the recommendations made by the committee earlier.
This only shows the committee is influential. It does not weaken the argument.
(c) Taking the award back would set a good example for others.
This actually strengthens the committee’s argument.
(d) There have been past cases where awards were taken back for misconduct.
This also supports/strengthens the argument by giving precedent.
(e) The committee consists of respected people.
This again strengthens credibility, not weakens the argument.
Thus, correct answer is option (a).
2. Many organizations have been resorting to recruitment based upon performance at graduate post-graduate level exams rather than conducting exams for the same purpose.
Which of the following statements would strengthen the argument given in the above statement? (IBPS PO 2013)
(a) A recent study shows no link of past performance with the performance in recruitment exams.
(b) The graduate/post-graduate exams are considered to be severely deficient in training in job related environment.
(c) Organisations which had undertaken recruitment on the basis of graduate/post-graduate exams report a significant drop in the quality of the recruited employees.
(d) Such policies would add to unemployment amongst students having below average performance in graduation or post-graduation.
(e) Such policies could save time, money and resources of the organisation which are wasted in the conduct of recruitment examinations.
Answer: (e)
Explanation:
The statement says: Many organisations are recruiting based on graduate / post-graduate exam performance instead of conducting separate recruitment exams.
Which option strengthens (supports / justifies) this practice?
So, we need a statement that shows why this new recruitment method is beneficial or reasonable.
Option-wise analysis
(a) A recent study shows no link of past performance with performance in recruitment exams.
This means graduate exam results do not predict recruitment-test success.
So it actually weakens the argument.
Because it suggests these organisations may be selecting the wrong candidates.
(b) Graduate exams are severely deficient in job-related training.
This weakens the argument.
If exams don’t test job-skills, using them for recruitment is a bad idea.
(c) Organisations that used this method report a significant drop in quality of recruits.
This clearly weakens the argument.
It shows the method produces poor employees.
(d) Such policies would increase unemployment among weaker academic students.
This is a social concern, but it does not support the recruitment method.
So it does not strengthen the argument.
(e) Such policies could save time, money and resources of the organisation which are wasted in the conduct of recruitment examinations.
This statement clearly supports / strengthens the practice, because it shows a strong benefit:
- Lower cost
- Less time
- Less administrative effort
Therefore, it provides a valid reason why organisations prefer this hiring method.
Thus, correct answer is option (e)
3. According to a recent government directive, all bank branches in rural areas should be computerized.
Which of the following statements would weaken the government’s argument? (IBPS PO 2013)
(a) Computerisation of bank branches in urban areas has helped in making their performance more efficient and fast.
(b) Lack of skilled and qualified manpower has been suitably substituted by computers in banks.
(c) Non-computerised bank branches in the rural areas have been proved to be as efficient as their computerized counterparts.
(d) The government has introduced a special test for computer knowledge in all recruitment exams for banks.
(e) Unemployment in the rural areas could be controlled by training more and more professionals in computers.
Answer: (c)
Explanation:
The government directive says:
All rural bank branches should be computerized.
This implies that the government believes computerization improves efficiency/performance.
To weaken the argument, we must choose a statement that shows:
- computerization is NOT necessary, or
- does not improve performance in rural branches.
Option-wise analysis
(a) Computerisation in urban banks improved efficiency.
This supports the idea of computerization, not weaken it.
(b) Lack of skilled manpower has been substituted by computers.
This again supports the need for computerization.
(c) Non-computerised rural bank branches are already as efficient as computerized ones.
This statement directly weakens the government’s argument because:
- If performance is already good without computers,
- then computerization is unnecessary.
It removes the justification for the directive.
So this most strongly weakens the policy.
(d) Government introduced a computer-knowledge test for bank recruitment.
This neither supports nor weakens the directive.
It’s just an additional measure.
(e) Computer training could reduce unemployment in rural areas.
This supports the decision indirectly (a positive side effect).
Thus, correct answer is option (c).
4. Nations do not compete with each other in the way corporations do. (IBPS PO 2014)
Which of the following most favours the weakness of the argument?
(a) Trade deficit is a sign of national strength, profits are a sign of corporate strength
(b) Increase in human development index improves national standing, increase in market share improves corporate standing
(c) Climate change negotiations lead to global improvement; CSR initiatives lead to image improvement
(d) Nations go to war to capture territory, corporates contend against each other to capture market share
(e) None of the above
Answer: (d)
Explanation
The statement says: “Nations do not compete with each other in the way corporations do.”
To weaken this argument, we must choose an option that shows that nations actually do compete in a manner similar to corporations.
Now examine the options:
(a) Trade deficit is linked with national strength, while profits are linked with corporate strength.
This highlights differences rather than similarities. So it does not weaken the statement.
(b) An improvement in human development index improves the standing of a nation, whereas an increase in market share improves a company’s standing.
Again, this shows different measures and does not prove similarity in competition.
(c) Climate change negotiations improve conditions globally, while CSR initiatives improve a company’s public image.
This relates to social responsibility, not direct competition. It does not show similarity.
(d) Nations go to war to capture territory, while corporations compete to capture market share.
Here there is a clear parallel:
Just as corporations compete aggressively to gain market share, nations also compete aggressively to expand their territorial or strategic dominance.
This shows that both pursue competitive goals in similar ways.
Therefore, this weakens the original claim that nations do not compete like corporations.
(e) None of the above
This is incorrect because option (d) already weakens the argument.
Thus, correct answer is option (d).
5. Civilization has taught us to be friendlier towards one another
Which of the following most favours the strength of the argument? (IBPS PO 2014)
(a) Cats are loyal to their children, whereas men are loyal to their communities
(b) Elephants move in a herd, whereas men live in nuclear families
(c) Lions protect their own territories, whereas men capture other men’s territories
(d) Nilgai and Cheetal stay together, whereas men of one race dominate another
(e) None of the above
Answer: (a)
Explanation
The statement is: “Civilization has taught us to be friendlier towards one another.”
We are asked to find the option that supports/strengthens this idea.
So we need a statement showing that human beings behave in a more social, cooperative or community-oriented way than animals, which can be seen as an effect of civilization.
Now consider each option:
(a) Cats are loyal to their children, whereas men are loyal to their communities.
This means:
- Animals show loyalty only within a very small circle (their own offspring).
- Humans, because of civilization, show loyalty and cooperation at a larger social level like communities.
This suggests civilization has expanded human friendliness beyond the family to wider society.
So this supports the argument.
(b) Elephants move in herds, whereas men live in nuclear families.
This suggests animals may actually be more group-oriented than humans.
So this does not support the claim.
(c) Lions protect their territory, whereas men capture others’ territories.
This makes humans look less friendly, not more.
So it weakens the argument.
(d) Nilgai and Cheetal stay together, whereas men of one race dominate another.
This again shows animals being more cooperative and humans being less friendly.
So it weakens the argument.
(e) None of the above
This is incorrect because option (a) clearly supports the given argument.
Thus, correct answer is option (a).
6. The rate of violent crime in this state is up to 30% from last year. The fault lies entirely in our system of justice. Recently our judges sentences have been so lenient that criminals can now do almost anything without fear of a long prison term.
The argument above would be weakened if it were true that [IBPS PO 2014]
(a) 85% of the other States in the nation have lower crime rates than does this state
(b) White-collar crime in this state has also increased by over 25% in the last year
(c) 35% of the police in this state have been laid off in the last year due to budget cuts
(d) Polls show that 65% of the population in this state opposes capital punishment
(e) None of the above
Answer: (c)
Explanation:
The argument says:
- Violent crime has increased by 30% this year.
- The writer blames the justice system.
- Specifically, they say judges are giving lenient sentences.
- Therefore, criminals are not afraid of punishment.
So the conclusion is: Lenient sentencing by judges is the reason for the rise in violent crime.
To weaken the argument, we should find an alternative reason for the increase in crime.
If another strong cause explains the rise, then the judges’ leniency may not be the real reason.
Option-wise analysis
(a) Other states have lower crime rates.
This does not explain why crime increased here.
So it does not weaken the argument.
(b) White-collar crime also increased.
This only adds information about another type of crime.
It does not explain the rise in violent crime or challenge the link with lenient sentencing.
So it does not weaken the argument.
(c) 35% of the police in this state have been laid off in the last year due to budget cuts.
This gives a strong alternative explanation:
- Fewer police
- Less law enforcement
- Criminals feel safer committing crimes
- Crime rises
This means the increase in crime may be due to reduced policing, not lenient judges.
So, this directly weakens the argument.
(d) People oppose capital punishment.
This is about opinion, not sentencing or crime rates.
So it does not weaken the argument.
(e) None of the above
Incorrect, because option (c) already weakens the argument.
Thus, correct answer is option (c).
7. In making decisions about important questions, it is desirable to be able to distinguish between ‘strong’ arguments and ‘weak’ arguments. ‘Strong’ arguments are those which are both important and directly related to the questions. ‘Weak’ arguments are those which are of minor importance and also may not be directly related to the question or may be related to a trivial aspect of the question. [SBI PO Mains 2019]
The question below is followed by three arguments numbered I, II and III. You have to decide which of the arguments is a ‘strong’ argument and which is a ‘weak’ argument is.
Statement: Should all the deemed universities be derecognized and attached to any of the central or state universities of India?
Arguments:
I. Yes, many of these deemed universities do not conform to the required standards of a full-fledged university and hence the level of education is compromised.
II. No, these deemed universities have been able to introduce innovative courses suitable to the requirement of various industries as they are free from strict government controls.
III. Yes, many such universities are basically money spinning activities and education takes a backseat in these institutions.
(a) Only I and II are strong
(b) Only II and III are strong
(c) Only I and III are strong
(d) All I, II and III are strong
(e) None of the above
Answer: (c)
Directions (Qs. 8–9): Read the following passage carefully and answer the questions that follow:
The Maternity Benefit (Amendment) Bill, 2016 was passed. Women working in the organised sector will now be entitled to paid maternity leave of 26 weeks, up from 12 weeks. The Bill also provides for maternity leave of 12 weeks to mothers adopting a child below the age of three months as well as to commissioning mothers (defined as a biological mother) who uses her egg to have a surrogate child. In such cases, 12-week period of maternity leave will be calculated from the date the child is handed over to the adoptive or commissioning mother.
8. Which of the following can be hypothesized from the Maternity Benefit Bill? [IBPS PO Mains 2019]
(I) Amendment to maternity bill will fortify to surrogacy.
(II) Commissioning mother will demand for 26 weeks leave same as normal mothers will get.
(III) Mothers will prefer to adopt a baby which is less than 3 months to other older babies.
(a) Only III
(b) All of the above
(c) Only I and II
(d) Only I
(e) None of these
Answer: (d)
Explanation:
Statement in the passage: The Maternity Benefit Amendment Bill increases maternity leave for working women and also includes adoptive and commissioning mothers under its scope.
We must find which statements can be reasonably hypothesized (logically suggested) from this law.
Statement I: “Amendment to maternity bill will fortify surrogacy.”
Meaning of this statement:
- The bill legally recognises commissioning mothers.
- Commissioning mothers exist only in the case of surrogacy.
- When a law formally acknowledges a practice and gives benefits under it, that practice receives recognition and legitimacy in society.
So, this statement can be logically understood from the bill because the amendment clearly brings surrogacy into the legal maternity framework.
Therefore, Statement I is a valid hypothesis.
Statement II: “Commissioning mother will demand for 26 weeks leave same as normal mothers will get.”
This statement predicts what commissioning mothers might demand in the future.
The passage does not talk about future protests or demands.
It only explains what the law currently provides.
So, this statement is speculative, not a logical conclusion from the text.
Statement III: “Mothers will prefer to adopt a baby which is less than 3 months.”
This assumes that mothers will now decide adoption based on the leave rule.
There is no mention of adoption choices or preferences in the passage.
So, this statement is not supported by the passage.
Only Statement I can be logically connected to the passage.
Thus, correct answer is option (d) Only I
9. Which of the following abrogate the contribution of surrogate mother? [IBPS PO Mains 2019]
(I) Generally surrogate mother demands a heavy amount for surrogacy.
(II) Surrogate mother gives a chance to fill the gap of happiness for commissioning couple.
(III) Society shows disrespect towards surrogate mother.
(a) Only II
(b) Only III
(c) Only I and III
(d) All of the above
(e) None of these
Answer: (c)
Explanation:
We must find which statements abrogate (reduce, undervalue, or weaken respect for) the contribution of surrogate mothers.
Statement I: “Generally surrogate mother demands a heavy amount for surrogacy.”
This statement portrays surrogacy as a financial transaction rather than an emotional or social service.
This reduces the moral value of the surrogate mother’s contribution.
So this statement undermines her contribution.
Statement II: “Surrogate mother gives a chance to fill the gap of happiness for commissioning couple.”
This statement appreciates surrogate mothers and highlights their positive role.
It gives credit rather than diminishing it.
So this statement does not undermine the contribution.
Statement III: “Society shows disrespect towards surrogate mother.”
This statement explains that surrogate mothers are not valued or respected socially.
This means their contribution is not honoured.
So, this statement does undermine their contribution.
Statements I and III diminish the social respect or moral value of surrogate mothers’ contribution.
Thus, correct answer is option (c) Only I and III
Directions (Q. 10–11): Study the following information carefully and answer the questions given below:
Rising concerns about pollution in major Indian cities have led to a dramatic increase in sales of home air purifiers. The air purifier segment, which was earlier limited to select pockets of top metro cities, is firming its foothold in smaller cities, and online channels, are emerging as a key facilitator to meet the consumer demand in such places. “The onset of winters, smog situation in various parts of the country and the current concerns around air normally raise the alarm around deteriorating air quality and indoor air pollution.” “An air purifier makes the most sense now, owing to the alarming levels of increasing air pollution in major cities around the country,” Eureka Forbes Managing Director and CEO said. New Delhi, which has been called the most polluted city in the world by the WHO, is not only the biggest buyer of air purifiers but is also the city that is seeing the fastest growth in sales of these devices.
10. Which of the following is/are definitely an effect(s) on the rising concern of pollution in the context of the passage? [IBPS PO Main 2020]
(a) The highest demand for air purifiers is from Delhi and its nearby states
(b) Indoor air has been 10 to 25 times more polluted than outside air
(c) The concern of government towards citizen has increased
(d) The sales of air purifiers has increased up to 150%
(e) Only 1 and 4
Answer: (a)
Explanation:
We must find which options are definite effects of rising concern about pollution, based on the passage.
The passage clearly states:
- Pollution concerns are rising.
- This has caused a dramatic increase in sales of air purifiers.
- Demand is expanding from metros to smaller cities.
- Online channels support this growth.
- New Delhi is the biggest and fastest-growing market for air purifiers.
Now check each option.
(a) “The highest demand for air purifiers is from Delhi and its nearby states.”
The passage states:
New Delhi is the biggest buyer and fastest-growing market.
This means Delhi has the highest demand.
Nearby states are not mentioned, but Delhi part is correct and clearly stated.
So this is a definite effect.
(b) “Indoor air has been 10 to 25 times more polluted than outside air.”
This number or comparison is never mentioned in the passage.
So this cannot be concluded.
(c) “The concern of government towards citizen has increased.”
There is no mention of government action or concern in the passage.
So this cannot be said to be an effect.
(d) “The sales of air purifiers has increased up to 150%.”
The passage mentions increase in sales but does not mention any percentage.
So this statement also cannot be concluded definitely.
(e) “Only 1 and 4”
But as seen above:
- (a) is supported
- (d) is not
So, this option is incorrect.
Thus, correct answer is option (a) Because only the statement about Delhi being the biggest buyer is clearly and definitely supported.
11. In the question below are given a statement followed by two courses of action numbered I and II. A course of action is a step or administrative decision to be taken for improvement, follow-up or further action regarding the problem, policy etc. Based on the information given in the statement to be true, then decide which of the suggested courses of action logically follow(s) for pursuing. [IBPS PO Main 2020]
Statement: In India, thousands of people die due to consumption of toxic alcohol. The government has taken certain steps previously but none of them were effective. Rohit, who has been recently appointed as the officer of narcotics department is given the project to suggest some of the schemes/advice to stop the consumption of toxic alcohol. After certain research, Rohit found that most of the toxic alcohol contains the ABC component. The ABC component is mainly used to build certain types of medicines. The permit of ABC component is accessible to any small companies.
Course of Actions:
I. Rohit suggest allowing the usage of ABC components to only Pharmaceutical companies.
II. Rohit suggests to publish an order that using ABC components in alcoholic drinks would be punishable by law.
(a) Only I follows
(b) Only II follows
(c) Either I or II follows
(d) Neither I nor II follows
(e) Both I and II follow
Answer: (e)
12. In making decisions about important questions, it is desirable to be able to distinguish between strong and weak arguments. Strong arguments are those, which are both important and directly related to the question. Weak arguments are those, which are of minor importance and also may not be directly related to the question or may be related to a trivial aspect of the question. The question below is followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments a Strong argument is and which a weak argument is.
Statement: Should animals be killed in the name of the laboratory experiments? [SBI PO Mains 2021]
Arguments:
I. Yes, they are available in abundance.
II. No, we have to support non-violence on every step of our lives.
(a) If only argument I is strong
(b) If only argument II is strong
(c) If either I or II is strong
(d) If neither I nor II is strong
(e) If both I and II are strong
Answer: (d)
Explanation:
We must judge strength strictly as per the given rule:
- A strong argument must be:
- important, and
- directly related to the question
If it is too general, emotional, vague, or irrelevant, it becomes weak.
Argument I: Yes, they are available in abundance.
Why it is weak (as per exam logic):
- It does not discuss ethics
- It does not discuss scientific necessity
- It is illogical because abundance alone never justifies killing
- It is trivial and insensitive
So, this is a weak argument.
Argument II: No, we have to support non-violence on every step of our lives.
This may sound morally appealing, but in exam reasoning:
- It is too general and emotional
- It does not discuss laboratory research, medicine, or public health
- It is not specifically related to animal testing
- It talks about life philosophy rather than the question
So, it is also treated as a weak argument.
Thus, correct answer is option (d) Neither I nor II is strong
Direction (Q. 13): The following question consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a ‘strong’ argument and which is a ‘weak’ argument. [SBI PO Main 2022]
13. Statement: Should there be only one rate of interest nor term deposits of varying durations in banks?
Arguments:
I. No, People will refrain from keeping money for longer duration resulting into reduction of liquidity level of banks.
II. Yes, This will be much simple for the common people and they may be encouraged to keep more money in banks.
(a) Argument I is strong
(b) Argument II are strong
(c) Either I or II is strong
(d) Neither I nor II is strong
(e) Both I and II are strong
Answer: (a)
Explanation:
Currently, longer deposits usually get higher interest.
The proposal suggests same rate for all durations.
Argument I: No. People will refrain from keeping money for longer duration resulting into reduction of liquidity level of banks.
Meaning:
- If the interest rate is same
- People will prefer short-term deposits
- Because there is no benefit in locking money for long duration
- So banks will receive less long-term funds
- That may hurt liquidity stability
This is:
- Logical
- Practical
- Directly connected to the banking system
- Shows a negative effect of the proposal
Therefore, Argument I is strong.
Argument II: Yes. This will be much simple for the common people and they may be encouraged to keep more money in banks.
Meaning:
- One single interest rate is easier to understand
- People won’t get confused
- So, deposits may increase
But:
- Banking customers already understand deposit schemes
- “Simplicity” alone is not a strong enough reason to change a national-level financial policy
- The claim that deposits will increase is speculative and not well-supported
So, it is not strong enough.
Therefore, Argument II is weak.
Conclusion
Argument I is Strong and Argument II is Weak
Thus, correct answer is option (a) Argument I is strong
DIRECTIONS (Q. 14–16): Read the below passage carefully and answer the questions:
Giving children computers in grade school is a waste of money and teachers time. These children are too young to learn how to use computers effectively and need to spend time on learning the basics, like arithmetic and reading. After all, a baby has to crawl before she can walk.
14. Which of the following, if true, would strengthen the speaker’s argument? [SBI PO Main–2023]
(a) studies showing computers are expensive
(b) research on the effect of computer games on children
(c) examples of high school students who use computers improperly
(d) proof that the cost of computers is coming down
(e) evidence that using computers makes learning to read difficult
Answer: (e)
Explanation:
Computers interfere with or do not help early learning.
Evaluate options:
(a) Cost — not relevant to learning
(b) Games — not same as learning computers
(c) High-school misuse — not relevant to small kids
(d) Falling cost — weakens financial objection
(e) Computers make reading difficult — directly supports idea
If computers make learning to read harder, then the claim that children should first focus on basic reading — without computers — becomes stronger.
Thus, correct answer is option (e) evidence that using computers makes learning to read difficult
15. Which of the following, if true, would weaken the speaker’s argument? [SBI PO Main–2023]
(a) a demonstration that computers can be used to teach reading and arithmetic
(b) analysis of the cost-effectiveness of new computers versus repairing old computers
(c) examples of adults who do not know how to use computers
(d) recent grade reports of students in the computer classes
(e) a visit to a classroom where computers are being used
Answer: (a)
Explanation:
We must find something that proves computers actually help early learning, contradicting the speaker.
Check each options:
(a) Demonstration that computers can be used to teach reading and arithmetic
This directly opposes the claim
because it proves computers help teach basics.
So, this weakens the argument.
(b) Cost-effectiveness analysis
Not related to learning or child readiness.
(c) Examples of adults who do not know computers
Not related to grade-school learning effectiveness.
(d) Grade reports of students in computer classes
This is vague and indirect.
(e) Visit to classroom using computers
Observation alone does not prove benefit or harm.
Thus, correct answer is option (a) a demonstration that computers can be used to teach reading and arithmetic.
16. Which of the following methods of argument is used in the previous passage? [SBI PO Main–2023]
(a) a specific example that illustrates the speaker’s point
(b) attacking the beliefs of those who disagree with the speaker
(c) relying on an analogy to prove the speaker’s point
(d) displaying statistics that back up the speaker’s point
(e) comparing different methods of learning
Answer: (e)
Explanation:
In the passage, the author argues that:
- Young children should first learn basic skills such as reading and arithmetic.
- Giving them computers too early is unnecessary and unhelpful.
To support this claim, the author compares two different learning approaches:
- Traditional learning of basics
- Learning with computers
The author concludes that traditional basic learning is more appropriate for small children, while computers should be introduced later.
So the main reasoning method used in the passage is comparison between different learning methods, rather than statistics, examples, or criticism of others.
Although the final line “a baby has to crawl before she can walk” sounds like an analogy, it only supports the larger comparison already being made between basic learning first and computer-assisted learning later.
Therefore, the dominant method of argument in the passage is Comparison of learning methods.
Thus, correct answer is option (e) comparing different methods of learning



