Hello

Chapter 6 – Work, Energy and Power – 11th Physics

42–63 minutes

6.0 Preview:

In this chapter, we will go through different work related concepts like “work done”, “power” and “energy”. We will also learn about various forms of energy; such as: mechanical energy, potential energy and kinetic energy in some detail.

In order to define work done as a vector quantity, we shall learn about dot product or scalar product. When A and B are two (vectors) forces acting on a body, the work done is given by their dot product, obtained as: A.B = A B cosθ. We shall also go through geometrical representation of the same. We shall then learn some of the properties of a scalar product (associative, distributive and cumulative).

Next, we will cover some of the aspects of work-energy theorem. Work energy theorem states that the change in kinetic energy of a particle is equal to the work done on it by the net force. We will then study scenarios where work done is zero due to: a) value of displacement or b) the angle of inclination between displacement vector and force or c) the value of force. We shall then learn to define work done as a function of displacement; given by: work done= force x displacement. We will learn also, the work done by graphical method. In graphical method of finding work done, the area under the Force-displacement curve represents the work done by the particle.

We will then learn to describe kinetic energy as the measure of the work an object can do by the virtue of its motion. We shall also establish a relation between potential and kinetic energies as “ $$mgh=1/2 mv^2$$ ”.

We shall then learn about Potential Energy as the energy possessed by a particle by virtue of its position; through the study of spring force. Next we shall define spring force as the restoring force exerted by a compressed or stretched spring upon an object attached to it. Then, we will define Hooke’s law that explains the behaviour of a spring force, in equation form as: $F_s = − kx$ (where, $F_s$ – spring force, k- spring constant and x- displacement of spring from its initial position (or) measure of elongation/compression).

You will find that the total energy though ideally translates into potential and kinetic energy for an object, there are other forms of energy that results due to resisting forces (such as friction) acting on it; like: heat energy and sound energy. Thus, we will learn in some detail about the various forms of energies that exist in nature; such as: Heat energy, Chemical energy and Nuclear energy. There are two types of chemical reactions that occur: Endothermic Reactions (where heat is absorbed during the reaction) and Exothermic Reactions (where heat is liberated during the reaction). There are also two types of Nuclear reactions: Nuclear fission reaction and Nuclear fusion reaction (Fission is the splitting of a heavy, unstable nucleus into two lighter nuclei, and fusion is the process where two light nuclei combine together releasing vast amounts of energy).

We will then define law of conservation of energy in various forms. One of the popular definitions of the law states that: “energy can neither be created, nor destroyed”. We will then learn about Power as a function of time and work done or as the rate of transfer of energy. We will then study the behaviour of particles when they undergo collision and few of the types of collisions will be dealt with.

6.1 Introduction

  • We might call any physical activity as work; like, running, painting, studying and so on.
  • Similarly, somebody who has the capacity to work for 14-16 hours a day is said to have a large stamina or great reserves of energy. Energy is thus our capacity to do work.
  • The word ‘power’ is also one such term used in everyday life with different meanings. You might call a punch “powerful”.
  • We shall find that there is a loose correlation between the physical definitions mentioned above as you try to picture them. In this chapter, you will learn to develop an understanding of these three physical quantities. To do this, you need to learn about Scalar Product of two Vectors.

6.1.1 The Scalar Product

Concept box:
A scalar product of two vectors is equal to the product of their magnitudes and the cosine of the angle between them.
  • There are two ways of multiplying vectors: one way known as the scalar product gives a scalar from two vectors and the other known as the vector product produces a new vector from two vectors.

We shall look at the vector product in Chapter 7.

  • The scalar product or dot product of any two vectors A and B, denoted as A.B (read as “A dot B”) is defined as:
    A.B = A B cosθ …. 6.1 a
    Where, θ is the angle between the two vectors as shown in Fig. 6.1a.
Note box:
Each vector, A and B, has a direction but their scalar product does not have a direction.

From Eq. (6.1a), we have
A.B = A (B cos θ)
= B (A cos θ)

  • Geometrically, “B cos θ” is the projection of B onto A as shown in Fig.6.1 (b) and “A cos θ” is the projection of A onto B as shown in Fig. 6.1 (c). The scalar product of two vectors can be constructed by taking the component of one vector in the direction of the other and multiplying it times the magnitude of the other vector.
  • So, A.B is the product of the magnitude of A and the component of B along A (which is B Cosθ). Alternatively, it is the product of the magnitude of B and the component of A along B (which is A cos θ).
    Properties of a scalar product:
  • Equation (6.1a) shows that the scalar product follows the commutative law:
    A.B = B.A
  • Scalar product obeys the distributive law:
    A. (B + C) = A.B + A.C
  • Further, A. (λ B) = λ (A.B)
    Where, λ is a real number.
Figure 6.1 (a) The scalar product of two vectors A and B is a scalar: A.B = A B cos θ. (b) B cos θ is the projection of B onto A. (c) A cos θ is the projection of A onto B.

For unit vectors, we have:

$$ \hat i.\hat i= \hat j.\hat j= \hat k .\hat k =1 $$

$$ \hat i. \hat j = \hat j. \hat k=\hat k.\hat k = 0 $$

Given two vectors

$$ A = A_x \hat i + A_y + A_z \hat k $$
$$ B = B_x \hat I + B_y \hat j +B_z \hat k $$

their scalar product is

$$ A.B=(A_x \hat i+ A_y \hat j + A_z \hat k).(B_x \hat i + B_y \hat j + B_z \hat k) $$
$$ = A_xB_x+A_yB_y+A_zB_z \hspace{10mm} ….. 6.1b $$

From the definition of scalar product and, (Eq.6.1b) we have:

$$ (i) A.A = A_xA_x+A_yA_y+A_zA_z $$
$$ Or, A^2=A^2_x+A^2_y+A^2_z \hspace{10mm} …6.1c$$

Example 6.1: Find the angle between force $ F = (3 \hat i + 4 \hat j 5 \hat k ) $ unit and displacement $d = (5 \hat i + 4 \hat j + 3 \hat k )$ unit. Also find the projection of F on d’

Solution:

$$ F.d = F_x d_x +F_y d_y +F_z d_z $$

$$ = 3 (5) + 4 (4) + (– 3) (3) $$

$$ = 16 \space unit $$

Hence F.d = F d cosθ = 16 unit

Now $ F.F = F^2 =F^2_x +F^2_y +F^2_z $

$$ = 9 + 16 + 25 $$

$= 50 \space unit $ and d.d = d^2 = d^2_x +d^2_y +d^2_z $

$ = 25 + 16 + 9 $

$= 50 \space unit $

∴ $ cos \space θ = \frac {16}{ \sqrt 50 \sqrt 50 } = \frac {16}{50} = 0.32 $

$$ θ = cos^{–1} \space 0.32 $$

6.2 Notions of Work and Kinetic Energy: The Work-Energy Theorem

Concept box:
Work energy theorem: The change in kinetic energy of a particle is equal to the work done on it by the net force.
  • The following relation for rectilinear motion under constant acceleration, “a” has been encountered in Chapter 3 as given below,
    $$ v^2 – u^2 = 2 as $$
    where, “u” and “v” are the initial and final speeds and “s”, the distance traversed. Multiplying both sides by m/2, we have,
    $$ \frac {1}{2} mv^2- \frac {1}{2}mu^2=mas = Fs \hspace{10mm… 6.2a
    Where, the last step is arrived at, from Newton’s Second Law.
  • We can generalise Eq. (6.1) to three dimensions by employing vectors
    $$ v^2 – u^2 = 2 a.d $$
    Once again, multiplying both sides by m/2, we obtain,
    $$ \frac {1}{2} mv^2 – \frac {1}{2} mu^2 = m \space a.d=F.d \hspace{10mm} ….. 6.2b $$

The above equation will be useful in defining work and kinetic energy.

Note box:
The left side of the equation is the difference in the quantity of: half the mass times the square of the speed, between initial and final values. Each of these values is an expression for ‘kinetic energy’, denoted by “K” . The right side is a product of the displacement and the component of the force along the displacement. This quantity is called ‘work’ and is denoted by W.

Then, from equation, 6.2:

$$ K_f – K_i = W \hspace{10mm} …6.3 $$

Where, $K_i$ and $K_f$ are respectively the initial and final kinetic energies of the object.
Thus, work is said to be done when a force acts on the body over a certain displacement.

Example 6.2: It is well known that a raindrop falls under the influence of the downward gravitational force and the opposing resistive force. The latter is known to be proportional to the speed of the drop but is otherwise undetermined. Consider a drop of mass1.00 g falling from a height 1.00 km. It hits the ground with a speed of 50.0 m s$^{-1}$. (a) What is the work done by the gravitational force? What is the work done by the unknown resistive force?

Solution: (a) The change in kinetic energy of the drop is
$$ ΔK = \frac {1}{2}mv^2 – 0 $$
$$ = \frac {1}{2}×10^{-3}×50×50 $$
$$ = 1.25 \space J $$
where we have assumed that the drop is initially at rest.
Assuming that g is a constant with a value 10 m/s2, the work done by the gravitational force is,
$$ W_g = mgh $$
$$= 10^{-3} × 10 × 10^ 3 $$
$$= 10.0 \space J $$
(b) From the work-energy theorem
$$ ΔK = W_g +W_r $$
where $W_r$ is the work done by the resistive force on the raindrop. Thus
$$ W_r = ΔK – W_g $$
$$= 1.25 −10 $$
$$ = − 8.75 \space J $$ is negative.

Questions for section, 6.1.1 and 6.2:

  1. Define Scalar product with the necessary equation. Also explain its geometrical significance with a figure.
  2. List the properties of a scalar product with algebraic expressions.
  3. Obtain equation for work-energy theorem in the form of equation, $$ \frac {1}{2} mv^2 – \frac {1}{2} mu^2 = m \space a.d=F.d \hspace{10mm… 6.2b $$

6.3 Work

As discussed above, work is related to force and the displacement over which it acts.

  • Now, consider a constant force “F” acting on an object of mass “m”. The object undergoes a displacement “d” in the positive x-direction as shown in Fig. 6.2.
Figure 6.2: An object undergoes a displacement d under the influence of the force F.
  • The work done by the force is defined to be the product of component of the force in the direction of the displacement and the magnitude of this displacement. Thus, it can be expressed as:
    W = (F cosθ )d = F.d ……6.4
  • We see that if there is no displacement, there is no work done even if the force is large.
Example box:
Imagine that you are pushing against a hard rigid brick wall, the force you exert on the wall will not move (or displace) the wall. Since your muscles are alternatively contracting and relaxing and internal energy is being used up and you might get tired. Although one would call this as “doing work”, no work is actually done by definition. Now, you may understand how the meaning of work in physics is different from that in everyday language.
Below is a list of scenarios where work done would be zero;
(i) When the displacement is zero as seen in the example above.
For instance, a weightlifter holding a 150 kg mass steadily on his shoulder for 30 s does no work on the load during this time.
(ii) When the force is zero.
For instance, when a block moving on a smooth horizontal table is not acted upon by any horizontal force (since there is no friction), despite of undergoing a large change in displacement.
(iii) When the force and displacement are mutually perpendicular.
This is so since, for θ = π/2 radians (= 90o). Therefore, cos (π /2) = 0. Thus, from equation 6.4, work done is zero.
For instance, for a block moving on a smooth horizontal table, the gravitational force, “mg” does no work since it acts at right angles to the displacement. If we assume that the moon’s revolution around the earth is perfectly circular, then the earth’s gravitational force does no work because moon’s instantaneous displacement is tangential while the earth’s force is radially inwards, thus making θ = π/2. Therefore, the work done by earth’s gravitational force would be zero. 
Note box:
1. Work can be both positive and negative. If θ is between 0o and 90o, cos θ in Eq. (6.4) is positive. If θ is between 90o and 180o, cos θ is negative.
2. Since the frictional force opposes displacement and θ = 180o. Then, the work done by friction is negative because, cos 180o = –1.
3. From Eq. (6.4) it is clear that work and energy have the same dimensions, $[ML^2T^{–2}]$.
4. The SI unit of work is joule (J), named after the famous British physicist James Prescott Joule.  

Table showing alternate units of work:

erg$10^{–7}$ J
electron volt (eV)$ 1.6 \times 10^{-19}$  \space J
calorie (cal)4.186 J
kilowatt hour (kWh)$3.6 \times 10^6  \space J$

Example 6.3: A cyclist comes to a skidding stop in 10 m. During this process, the force on the cycle due to the road is 200 N and is directly opposed to the motion. (a) How much work does the road do on the cycle?(b) How much work does the cycle do on the road?

Solution: Work done on the cycle by the road is the work done by the stopping (frictional) force on the cycle due to the road.

(a) The stopping force and the displacement make an angle of $180^o$ (π rad) with each other.Thus, work done by the road,

$$ W_r = Fd \space cosθ $$
$$ = 200 × 10 × cos π $$
$$= – 2000 \space J $$

It is this negative work that brings the cycle to a halt in accordance with WE theorem.

(b) From Newton’s Third Law an equal and opposite force acts on the road due to the cycle. Its magnitude is 200 N. However, the road undergoes no displacement. Thus, work done by cycle on the road is zero.

6.4 Kinetic Energy

As noted earlier, if an object of mass, “m” has velocity “v”, its kinetic energy, “K” is
$$ K= \frac {1}{2} m \space v.v = \frac {1}{2}mv^2 \hspace{10mm} …6.5$$

Note box: Kinetic energy is a scalar quantity.
  • The kinetic energy of an object is a measure of the work an object can do by the virtue of its motion.
  • The kinetic energy that manifests in different objects by virtue of their motion can be harnessed for some useful purposes; like, a fast flowing stream is used to grind corn. Sailing ships employ the kinetic energy of the wind.
  • Similarly, the Table 6.2 below lists the kinetic energies for various bodies in motion:
    Typical kinetic energies (K):
Table 6.2 Typical kinetic energies (K):

Example 6.4: In a ballistics demonstration a police officer fires a bullet of mass 50.0 g with speed 200 m s$^{-1}$ (see Table 6.2) on soft plywood of thickness 2.00 cm. The bullet emerges with only 10% of its initial kinetic energy. What is the emergent speed of the bullet?

Solution: The initial kinetic energy of the bullet is $mv^2/2$ = 1000 J. It has a final kinetic energy of 0.1× 1000 = 100 J. If $v_f$ is the emergent speed of the bullet,
$$ \frac {1}{2} mv^2_f = 100 \space J $$
$$ v_f = \sqrt { \frac { 2×100 \space J}{0.05\space kg} } $$
$$ = 63.2 \space m s^{–1} $$
The speed is reduced by approximately 68% (not 90%).

6.5 Work Done by a Variable Force

  • A constant force is rare. It is the variable force, which is more commonly encountered.
  • Fig. 6.2 is an example for a varying force in one dimension.
  • During such motion, if there is a small displacement, Δx due to application of force, F (x) (which is approximately a constant force); then, the work done is:
    ΔW =F (x) Δx
Figure 6.3a
  • This is illustrated in Fig. 6.3(a) as above. Adding successive rectangular areas in Fig. 6.3(a) we get the total work done as:
    $$ W \cong \Sigma_{x_f}^{x_i}F(x) \Delta x ..6.6 $$
    Where, the summation is from the initial position xi to the final position xf.
  • When we allow the displacement to approach zero, the number of terms to sum (or add) increases without a limit (graphically, the plot gets divided into infinite number of small fragments of displacements). However, the sum approaches a definite value equal to the area under the curve (which denotes the work done) in Fig. 6.3(b). This work done is denoted by:
    $$ W = \lim_{\Delta x \to 0 } \Sigma_{x_f}^{x_i} F(x) \Delta x $$
    $$ = \int_{x_i}^{x_f} F(x) dx \hspace{10mm} …6.7$$
    Where, ‘lim’ stands for the limit of the sum when Δx tends to zero.
  • Thus, for a varying force the work done can be expressed as a definite integral of force over displacement (see also Appendix 3.1). The graphical way of finding work done can be perceived from the graph depicted below.

Figure 6.3 (a) The shaded rectangle represents the work done by the varying force F(x), over the small displacement Δx, ΔW = F(x)Δx. (b) adding the areas of all the rectangles we find that for Δx → 0, the area under the curve is exactly equal to the work done by F(x).*

Questions from sections 6.3 to 6.5:

  1. Define work done.
  2. List the cases where we obtain theoretical work done as 0. Also, obtain generic equations for cases where work done would be negative, positive and zero by inserting different values of θ in the equation of “work done”.
  3. What is the SI unit of “work done”? Also give its dimensional formula.
  4. Define Kinetic energy. List the applications of Kinetic energy in daily life and in technological developments.
  5. Give the equation for work done due to small displacement, Δx.
  6. How would you find the work done by graphical method? Explain with the help of a graph.

6.6 The Work-Energy Theorem for a Variable Force

The time rate of change of kinetic energy is;

$$ \frac {dK}{dt} = \frac {d}{dt} \bigg( \frac {1}{2}mv^2 \bigg) $$

$$ = m \frac {dv}{dt}v $$
$$=Fv(from \space Newton’s Second \space Law) $$
$$ = F \frac {dx}{dt} $$

Thus $ dK=Fdx $

Integrating from the initial position $(x_i )$ to final position $( x_f )$, we have
$$ \int_{K_i}^{K_f}dK= \int_{x_i}^{x_f} Fdx …6.7$$

where, $K_i$ and $K_f$ are the initial and final kinetic energies corresponding to $x_i$ and $x_f$.

$$ or \space K_f-K_i = \int_{x_i}^{x_f}Fdx \hspace{10mm} …6.8a $$

From Eq.(6.7) , it follows that

$$ K_f-K_i=W \hspace{10mm} (6.8b) $$

Note box:
1. Work energy theorem does not completely incorporate the dynamic information of Newton’s second law. That is, it is an integral form of the law. Work-energy theorem involves an integral over an interval of time. That is, the “time information” contained in the Newton’s second law is integrated over and not explicitly available as a part of the definition of the Work energy theorem.

2. Another observation is that Newton’s second law (for two or three dimensions) is in vector form whereas; the work-energy theorem is in scalar form. Since it is in scalar form, information with respect to directions contained in Newton’s second law is not present.

Example 6.6: A block of mass m = 1 kg, moving on a horizontal surface with speed $v_i = 2 ms^{–1} $ enters a rough patch ranging from x = 0.10 m to x = 2.01 m. The retarding force $F_r$ on the block in this range is inversely proportional to x over this range,
$$ F_r = \frac { -k}{x} \space for \space 0.1 < x < 2.01 \space m $$ = 0 for x < 0.1m and x > 2.01 m where k = 0.5 J. What is the final kinetic energy and speed $v_f$ of the block as it crosses this patch?

Solution: From Eq. (6.8a)
$$ K_f = K_i + \int_{0.1}^{ 2.01} \frac {(-k)}{x}dx $$
$$ = \frac {1}{2} mv^2_i – k \space ln (x) |{0.1}^ {2.01 } $$ $$ =\frac {1}{2} mv^2_i – k \space ln (2.01/0.1 ) $$ $$ = 2 − 0.5 \space ln (20.1) $$ $$ = 2 − 1.5 = 0.5 \space J $$ $$ v_f = \sqrt { 2 K_f /m } =1\space m s^{−1} $$ Here, note that ln is a symbol for the natural logarithm to the base e and not the logarithm to the base 10 $[ ln X = log_e X = 2.303 \space log{10} X]$.

6.7 The Concept of Potential Energy

The word potential suggests possibility or capacity for action. The term “potential energy” often refers to the ‘stored’ energy.

Definition box: Potential energy is the energy possessed by a body by virtue of its position relative to others.
Example box:
1. A stretched bow-string possesses potential energy. When it is released, potential energy manifests into the kinetic energy and the arrow flies off at a great speed.
2. The faults (or the breaks in the earth’s crust) behave like ‘compressed springs’. They possess a large amount of potential energy. An earthquake results when these fault lines readjust.

From the above examples, we can conclude that:

  • Potential energy is the ‘stored energy’ by virtue of the position or configuration of a body.
  • The stored energy in the body is released in the form of kinetic energy.
    To understand the concept of potential energy better, let us establish a scenario and derive equations, as follows:
  • The gravitational force on a ball of mass, “m” is mg. (“g” may be treated as a constant near the earth’s surface.)
  • Let us raise the ball up to a height, “h” (where, height of the ball<<Radius of the earth so that we can ignore the variation of g near the earth’s surface and since “h” is in upward direction, it is considered positive).
  • Then, the work done by the external agency against the gravitational force is: “mgh”. This work is stored as potential energy and is called Gravitational potential energy of an object. It is as a function of the height, “h” and is thus denoted by V(h). The gravitational potential energy of an object is the negative of work done in raising the object to that height.
Note box:
To lift an object to a height ‘h’ the work necessary is the exact opposite of the Gravitational force exerted on that body at a height ‘h’.

V (h) = mgh

  • If “h” is taken as a variable, it is easily seen that the gravitational force,“F” equals the negative of the derivative of V(h) with respect to h. Thus,
    $$ F = – \frac {d}{dh} V(h)= – mg $$
    The negative sign indicates that the gravitational force is downward.
  • When released, the ball comes down with an increasing speed. Just before it hits the ground, its speed is given by the kinematic relation,
    $$v^2 = 2gh$$
  • This equation can be written as:
    $$ \frac {1}{2}mv^2=mgh $$

Q and A:

What is the significance of the equation $$ \frac {1}{2}mv^2=mgh $$ (that relates potential and kinetic energies)?

The equation implies that, the gravitational potential energy of the object at height, h, when the object is released, manifests itself as kinetic energy of the object as it travels through the air and finally reaches the ground, at which point the energy becomes zero.

Mathematically, (for motion in one dimension) the potential energy, V(x) is defined if the force F(x) can be written as:
$ F(x)= – \frac {dV}{dx} $

This implies that
$$ \int_{x_i}^{x_f} F(x)dx = – \int_{V_i}^{V_f} dV = V_i-V_f $$

Concept box:
1. A conservative force is a force with the property that the work done in moving a particle between two points is independent of the taken path. For example, imagine lifting a book, the book has a stored potential by the virtue of the height at which it is positioned in air. This stored potential energy immediately manifests into kinetic energy, the moment the book is let go. Similarly, a spring possesses potential energy in the compressed state which manifests as kinetic energy. You will learn more about it in the sections to come. Thus, from the examples, we can conclude that gravity is a conservative force since the work that we did in lifting the book is stored (available in the form of kinetic energy).  

2. On the contrary, non-conservative forces are those forces in which work done does depend on the path traversed. For instance, imagine you are pushing a book against friction, the (theoretical) work done against friction is lost in pushing and this frictional force will not manifest into kinetic energy. Similarly, any resistance offered to an object in air due to the air resistance results in a decrease of its speed, thus the work done is lost to resistance of air. Therefore, not all potential energy gets converted to kinetic energy. Some of it is lost while the object works on overcoming the resistance. Thus, these non-conservative forces are also known as dissipative forces.

Therefore, for a conservative force, the change in potential energy is mathematically equal to the negative of the work done and can be expressed as follows:
ΔV = − F(x) Δx (6.9)

6.8 The Conservation of Mechanical Energy

  • Suppose that a body undergoes displacement, Δx under the action of a conservative force, F. Then from the Work Energy theorem we have change in kinetic energy, Δk as:
    ΔK = F(x) Δx
  • If the force is conservative, the potential energy function V(x) can be defined such that
    − ΔV = F(x) Δx
  • By adding the above equations as below;
    ΔK + ΔV = 0
    Δ(K + V ) = 0 ……… (6.10)
    We find that, sum of the kinetic and potential energy of the body is a constant over the whole path from initial to final points (that is, from xi to xf). This means that,
    $$ K_i+V(x_i)=K_f+V(x_f) \hspace{10mm} (6.11)$$
  • The quantity K +V(x) is called the total mechanical energy of the system. Individually the kinetic energy, ΔK and the potential energy V(x) may vary from point to point, but the sum is a constant. Thus, the term ‘conservative force’ is used.
  • Let us now consider some of the definitions of a conservative force:
    • A force, F(x) is conservative if it can be derived from a scalar quantity, V(x) as given by Eq. (6.9).
    • The work done by the conservative force depends only on the end points. This can be seen from the relation,
      $$ W = K_f – K_i = V(x_i) – V(x_f) $$
    • A third definition states that the work done by this force in a closed path is zero. This is once again apparent from Eq. (6.11) since, $x_i = x_f$.
  • Thus, the principle of conservation of total mechanical energy can be stated as: The total mechanical energy of a system is conserved if the forces, doing work on it, are conservative.
  • Fig. 6.5 depicts a ball of mass, “m” being dropped from a cliff of height, “H”.
Figure 6.5: The conversion of potential energy to kinetic energy for a ball of mass m dropped from a height, H
  • The total mechanical energies $E_0$, $E_h$ (the subscript, “h” denotes a height when the ball is at some point in air during its travel upwards), and $E_H$ of the ball at the indicated heights: zero (ground level), height- h and height- H respectively are:
    insert equations from 6.11a to 6.11d, page 136, NCERT with explanations
    $$E_H = mgH ..(6.11a) $$
    $$E_h = mgh + \frac {1}{2}mv^2_h …(6.11b)$$
    $$E_o = (1/2)mv^2 …(6.11c)$$
    The constant force is a special case of a spatially dependent force F(x). Hence, the mechanical energy is conserved. Thus
    $$ E_H = E_o$$
    $$or, mgH= \frac {1}{2}mv^2_f$$
    $$v_f = \sqrt {2gH$$
    Further,$$E_H=E_h$$
    Which implies,
    $$v^2_h =2g(H-h) … (6.11d)$$
  • At the height H, the energy is purely potential. It is partially converted to kinetic at height h and is fully kinetic at ground level. Total energy = PE + KE. When h=0 i.e at ground level, then the only energy is = KE.
  • This illustrates the conservation of mechanical energy.

Q and A:

How is the energy of an object completely kinetic when it touches the ground? Should it not be conserved as potential energy?

At ground level, the height, H becomes 0. The equation for potential energy given by “mgh” thus becomes, “m.g.0=0”. Therefore, the potential energy becomes zero and the only other energy that would exist at H=0 (or ground) would be kinetic.

Example 6.7: A bob of mass m is suspended by a light string of length L . It is imparted a horizontal velocity $v_o$ at the lowest point A such that it completes a semi-circular trajectory in the vertical plane with the string becoming slack only on reaching the topmost point, C. This is shown in Fig. 6.6. Obtain an expression for (i) $v_o$; (ii) the speeds at points B and C; (iii) the ratio of the kinetic energies ($K_B/K_C$) at B and C. Comment on the nature of the trajectory of the bob after it reaches the point C.

Solution: (i) There are two external forces on the bob : gravity and the tension (T ) in the string. The latter does no work since the displacement of the bob is always normal to the string. The potential energy of the bob is thus associated with the gravitational force only. The total mechanical energy E of the system is conserved. We take the potential energy of the system to be zero at the lowest point A. Thus, at A :
$$ E = \frac {1}{2} mv^2_o \hspace{20mm} (6.12) $$
$$ T_A-mg = \frac {mv^2_o}{L} \hspace{10mm} [Newton’s \space Second \space Law] $$
where $T_A$ is the tension in the string at A. At the highest point C, the string slackens, as the tension in the string ($T_C$) becomes zero.
Thus, at C
$$ E = \frac {1}{2}mv^2_c +2mgL \hspace{20mm} (6.13) $$
$$ mg = \frac {mv^2_c}{L} \hspace{10mm} [Newton’s \space Second \space Law] \hspace{10mm} (6.14) $$
where $v_C$ is the speed at C. From Eqs. (6.13) and (6.14)
$$ E = \frac {5}{2}mgL $$
Equating this to the energy at A
$$ \frac {5}{2}mgL = \frac {m}{2}v^2_o $$
Or ,$ v_O = \sqrt {5gL} $
(ii) It is clear from Eq. (6.14)
$$ v_C= \sqrt { gL} $$
At B, the energy is
$$ E = \frac {1}{2}mv_B^2 +mgL $$
Equating this to the energy at A and employing the result from (i), namely $v^2_o=5 gL$ ,
$$ \frac {1}{2}mv_B^2+mgL =\frac {1}{2} mv^2_o $$
$$ = \frac {5}{2}mgL $$
∴ $$ v_B = \sqrt {3gL} $$
(iii) The ratio of the kinetic energies at B and C is :
$$ \frac {K_B}{K_C} = \frac { \frac {1}{2}mv_B^2}{ \frac {1}{2}mv^2_C} = \frac {3}{1} $$
At point C, the string becomes slack and the velocity of the bob is horizontal and to the left. If the connecting string is cut at this instant, the bob will execute a projectile motion with horizontal projection akin to a rock kicked horizontally from the edge of a cliff. Otherwise, the bob will continue on its circular path and complete the revolution.

Questions from sections 6.6 to 6.8:

  1. Obtain the equation for kinetic energy in integral form.
  2. Define potential energy.
  3. Show that kinetic energy is equal to the potential energy stored in a body through equations.
  4. What are conservative and non-conservative forces? Explain each type with an example.
  5. Obtain equations and explain the total mechanical energy of a ball, when it is:
    a) at ground level
    b) at some point in air (say at a height, h)
    c) at the highest point it reaches (say height, H)

6.9 The Potential Energy of a spring

Concept box:
The spring force is the force exerted by a compressed or stretched spring upon an object attached to it. However, this force tries to restore the spring back to its original state.

Let us now consider one such spring since it would be the best example to analyse a variable-conservative-force,

Figure 6.7 Illustration of the spring force with a block attached to the free end of the spring. (a) The spring force $F_s$ is zero when the displacement x from the equilibrium position is zero. (b) For the stretched spring x > 0 and $F_s$ < 0 (c) For the compressed spring x < 0 and $F_s$ > 0

  • Look at Fig. 6.7(a), which shows a block attached to a spring, resting on a smooth horizontal surface. The other end of the spring is attached to a rigid wall. (The spring is light and may be treated as mass-less).
  • In an ideal spring, the spring force, $“F_s”$ is proportional to “x” where x is the displacement of the block from the equilibrium position. The displacement could be either positive as shown in Fig. 6.7(b) or negative as shown in Fig. 6.7(c). This law of force for the spring is called Hooke’s law and is mathematically stated as:
    $$ F_s = − kx $$
Note box:
The constant “k” is called the spring constant. Its unit is N $m^{-1}$. The spring is said to be stiff if, k is large and soft if k is small.
  • Now, suppose we pull the block outwards as shown in Fig. 6.7(b), the extension is $x_m$, the work done by the spring force is;

$$ W_s = \int_{0}^{x_m} F_s dx = – \int_{0}^{x_m} kx \space dx $$
$$ = – \frac {kx^2_m}{2} \hspace{10mm} (6.15) $$

  • This expression may also be obtained by considering the area of the triangle as in Fig. 6.7(d) because area under an “F-x” graph represents the work done, as you already know.

Figure 6.7(d) The plot of $F_s$ versus x. The area of the shaded triangle represents the work done by the spring force. Due to the opposing signs of $F_s$ and x, this work done is negative, $W_s= -km^2 / 2$

  • Note that the work done by the external pulling force, “F” is positive. Thus, it would be –ve of equation 6.15 as expressed below:
    $$ W = + \frac {kx^2_m}{2} \hspace{10mm} (6.16) $$

Q and A:

Why is the external pulling-spring-force positive?

The external spring force is positive because it is the force (that acts in positive direction) that overcomes the restoring spring force (which is directed in the negative x-direction).

  • The same is true when the spring is compressed with a displacement say, $x_c$< 0 (that is, $x_c$ is negative since it acts in the negative direction to restore it from an elongated state). The spring force does work: $W_s= -kxc^2/ 2 $while the external force, F does work: $+kxc^2/ 2$.
  • If the block is moved from an initial displacement $x_i$ to a final displacement $x_f$, the work done by the spring force $W_s$ is:

$$ W_s =- \int_{x_i}^{x_f} k \space x \space dx = \frac {k \space x_i^2}{2}- \frac {kx^2_f}{2} \hspace{10mm} (6.17) $$

  • Thus the work done by the spring force depends only on the end points (as you may recollect how conservative forces act). Specifically, if the block is pulled from $x_i$ and allowed to return to $x_i$;
    $$ W_s =- \int_{x_i}^{x_f} k \space x \space dx = \frac {k \space x_i^2}{2}- \frac {kx^2_f}{2} \hspace{10mm} $$
    = 0 (6.18)
  • Therefore, the work done by the spring force in a cyclic process is zero.
  • We have clearly demonstrated that the spring force;
    (a) is position dependent, as stated by Hooke’s law: ($F_s$ = − kx). As you may recollect from definition of potential energy in section, 6.7; potential energy is given by − dV/dx. − dV/dx is thus equal to −k x, the spring force.
    (b) (b) does work which only depends on the initial and final positions (as you will find in Eq. (6.17)). Thus, the spring force is a conservative force.
  • We define the potential energy V(x) of the spring to be zero when block and spring system is in the equilibrium position. For an extension or compression, “x” the above analysis suggests that:
    $$V(x) = \frac {kx^2}{2} \hspace {10mm} (6.19) $$
  • If the block of mass, “m” in Fig. 6.7 is extended to $x_m$ and released, then its total mechanical energy at any arbitrary point, x (where x lies between – $x_m$ and + $x_m$) can be determined. That is, the total energy is constant and is shifted back and forth between kinetic energy and potential energy. The conservation of energy for this system (which is nothing but the total mechanical energy) in equation form is thus: $$ \frac {1}{2}k \space x^2_m = \frac {1}{2}k \space x^2+ \frac {1}{2}mv^2 $$
Note box:
Mechanical energy is the energy that is possessed by an object due to its motion or due to its position. For instance, a moving baseball possesses mechanical energy due to both its high speed (kinetic energy) and its vertical position above the ground (gravitational potential energy). Hence, the above equation for potential energy is a sum of the two energies.  
  • Let us insert, x=0. That is, when the block is at equilibrium position, we find that velocity and kinetic energy take maximum value. Then, the above equation takes the form:
    $$ \frac {1}{2} m \space v^2_m = \frac {1}{2} k \space x^2m …(A) $$
    Where, $v_m$ is maximum speed.
    $$ v_m = \sqrt { \frac {k}{m} } x_m … (B)$$

Q and A:

How do we know that “v” becomes “$v_m$” (or), that value of kinetic energy is maximum at the equilibrium state?

The answer lies in equation-A itself. Notice how we obtain total potential energy on the left-hand side as being equal to the total kinetic energy on the right-hand side. You might have now guessed how.

The total potential energy is completely manifested into kinetic energy; thus, the body attains maximum kinetic energy that it possibly could have! Therefore, the velocity (that directly varies as the kinetic energy) also attains the maximum value, $v_m$.

Note box:
In equation B above, “k/m” has the dimensions of [T-2] and our equation is thus, dimensionally correct. (Try to verify by inserting dimensions in the equation)

Example 6.8: To simulate car accidents, auto manufacturers study the collisions of moving cars with mounted springs of different spring constants. Consider a typical simulation with a car of mass 1000 kg moving with a speed 18.0 km/h on a smooth road and colliding with a horizontally mounted spring of spring constant 6.25 × 10^3 \spaceN m$^{–1}$. What is the maximum compression of the spring?

Solution: At maximum compression the kinetic energy of the car is converted entirely into the potential energy of the spring. The kinetic energy of the moving car is
$$ K = \frac {1}{2} mv^2 $$
$$ =\frac {1}{2} × 10^3 ×5×5 $$
$$ K =1.25 × 10^4 \space J $$
where we have converted 18 km h$^{–1}$ to 5 m s$^{–1}$ [It is useful to remember that 36 km h$^{–1}$ = 10 m s$^{–1}$].At maximum compression $x_m$, the potential energy V of the spring is equal to the kinetic energy K of the moving car from the principle of conservation of mechanical energy.
$$ V = \frac {1}{2} k\space x^2_m $$
$$= 1.25 × 10^4 \space J $$
We obtain
$$ x_m = 2.00 \space m $$
We note that we have idealised the situation. The spring is considered to be massless. The surface has been considered to possess

Example 6.9: Consider Example 6.7 taking the coefficient of friction, μ, to be 0.5 and calculate the maximum compression of the spring.

Solution: In presence of friction, both the spring force and the frictional force act so as to oppose the compression of the spring as shown in Fig. 6.9.
We invoke the work-energy theorem, rather than the conservation of mechanical energy.
The change in kinetic energy is

$$ ΔK = K_f – K_i = 0 – \frac {1}{2} mv^2 $$

The work done by the net force is
$$ W = – \frac {1}{2}kx^2_m− μ \space m \space g \space x_m $$

Equating we have
$$ \frac {1}{2} mv^2 = \frac {1}{2}kx^2_m + μ \space m \space g \space x_m $$

Now μmg = 0.5 × 10$^3$ × 10 = 5 × 10$^3$ N (taking g =10.0 m s$^{-2}$). After rearranging the above equation we obtain the following quadratic equation in the unknown $x_m$

$$ k \space x^2_m + 2 \space μ \space m \space g \space x_m − m v^2 = 0 $$
$$ x_m = \frac {-μ \space m \space g + [μ^2m^2 g^2 + mkv^2]^{1/2}}{k} $$

where we take the positive square root since $x_m$ is positive. Putting in numerical values we obtain
$$ x_m = 1.35 \space m $$

which, as expected, is less than the result in Example 6.8.

If the two forces on the body consist of a conservative force $F_c$ and a non-conservative force $F_{nc}$ , the conservation of mechanical energy formula will have to be modified. By the WE theorem
$$ (F_c+ F_{nc} ) Δx = ΔK $$
But $ F_c \space Δx = − ΔV $$

Hence, $ Δ(K + V) = F_{nc} \space Δx $

$$ ΔE = F_{nc} \space Δx $$

where E is the total mechanical energy. Over the path this assumes the form
$$ E_f – E_i = W_{nc} $$

Where $W_{nc}$ is the total work done by the non-conservative forces over the path. Note that unlike the conservative force, $W_{nc}$ depends on the particular path i to f.

Questions for section 6.9:

  1. State Hooke’s law with the necessary equation.
  2. Define spring force.
  3. Explain how mechanical energy is conserved with the necessary equation.
  4. Obtain the expression for maximum velocity in the form: $$ v_m = \sqrt { \frac {k}{m} } x_m $$

6.10 Various Forms of Energy: The Law of Conservation Of Energy

We have seen that it can be classified into two distinct categories: one based on motion, namely kinetic energy; the other on configuration (or position), namely potential energy. Energy comes in many forms which transform into one another, about which you will learn.

6.10.1 Heat

Example box:
Example 1:
A block of mass, “m” sliding on a rough horizontal surface with speed, “v0”comes to a halt over a distance “$x_0$”. The work done by the force of kinetic friction, f over $x_0$ is $–f.x_0$.
By the work-energy theorem, m $v_0^2 /2 = f.x_0$ .
As you already know, friction is a non-conservative force. The kinetic energy of the block is thus ‘lost’ due to the frictional force (that is, the complete potential energy of the block does not transform into kinetic energy on motion, but only a part does).
In order to account for this “lost energy”, we examine the block and the table. We will find that there is a slight increase in their temperatures. The work done by friction is thus not actually ‘lost’, but is transferred as heat energy. The heat energy raises the internal energy of the block and the table.  

Example 2:
In winter, in order to feel warm, we generate heat by vigorously rubbing our palms together. As you now know, rubbing of palms creates heat due to the friction that arises during rubbing.
However, you will learn how internal energy is also associated with the ceaseless, often random, motion of molecules.
Concept box:
In thermodynamics, the internal energy of a system is energy contained within the system, excluding the kinetic energy of motion of the system as a whole and the potential energy of the system as a whole due to external force fields. It keeps account of the gains and losses of energy of the system that are due to changes in its internal state.
For instance, 1 kg of water releases about 42000 J of energy when it cools by 10 °C.

6.10.2 Chemical Energy

Concept box:
1. In chemistry, chemical energy is the potential of a chemical substance to undergo a transformation through a chemical reaction from one substance to another. Batteries, food, and gasoline are examples for those substances that undergo a chemical change. 2. Breaking or making of chemical bonds involves liberation or absorption of energy from a chemical system. Thus, this process also constitutes for a change in chemical energy.
3. A chemical compound is a substance which is composed of two or more elements.

Now study the following cases where you will observe a change in chemical energy;

  • As you know, fire was first created by rubbing two flint stones together (mechanical energy), to heat them up and to ignite. This was used to burn a heap of dry leaves (chemical energy), which then provided sustained warmth.
  • A matchstick ignites into a bright flame when struck against a specially prepared chemical surface.
  • The lighted matchstick, when applied to a firecracker, results in a spectacular display of sound and light.

In the above cases, Chemical energy arises due to the difference in binding energies of the molecules participating in the chemical reaction.

  • A stable chemical compound has less energy than the separated parts.
  • A chemical reaction is basically a rearrangement of atoms.
  • If the total energy of the reactants is more than the products of the reaction, heat is released and the reaction is said to be an exothermic reaction. If the reverse is true, that is, if the total energy of products is greater than that of the reactants, then, heat is absorbed and the reaction is endothermic reaction. For example, Coal consists of carbon and a kilogram of it when burnt releases $ 3 \times 10^7 \space J $of energy.
  • Chemical energy is associated with binding forces that give rise to the stability of substances. These forces bind atoms into molecules, molecules into polymeric chains and so on.
  • The chemical energy arising from the combustion of coal, cooking gas, wood and petroleum is essential to our daily existence.

6.10.4 The Equivalence of Mass and Energy

  • Although matter might change its phase from one form to another, matter is neither destroyed, nor created. For example, glacial ice could melt into a gushing stream.
  • Albert Einstein however, showed that mass and energy are equivalent and are related in the following way:
    $$E = mc^2 \hspace{10mm} (6.20)$$ Where, “c” is the speed of light in vacuum, approximately $ 3 \times 10^8 \space m \space s^{–1}$.
  • From the equation, we find that large amount of energy is associated with a mere kilogram of matter as obtained below; $$ E = 1 \times (3 \times 10^8)^2 J = 9 \times 10^{16} \space J.$$ This is equal to the annual electrical output of a large (3000 MW) power generating system.

6.10.5 Nuclear Energy

Concept box:
Nuclear Fission is the splitting of a heavy, unstable nucleus into two lighter nuclei, thus releasing energy. Nuclear fusion is the process where two light nuclei combine together releasing vast amounts of energy.
  • The fission and fusion reactions in bombs are illustrations of above equivalence of mass and energy [refer equation-(6.20)] where mass gets manifested into an enormous amount of energy.
  • Similarly, the explanation of the life-nourishing energy output of the sun is also based on the above equation.
  • In fusion reaction, four light hydrogen nuclei fuse to form a helium nucleus whose mass is less than the sum of the masses of the reactants (hydrogen atoms). This mass difference (between sum of reactants and products), called the mass defect Δm is the source of energy: $(Δm)c^2$.
  • In nuclear fission, a heavy nucleus like uranium$ \ce{^{235}_{902}U}$, is split by a neutron into lighter nuclei. Like in fusion, the final mass is less than the initial mass and the mass-difference translates into energy.
  • This energy can be tapped to provide electrical energy as is done in nuclear power plants (controlled nuclear fission) or can be employed in making nuclear weapons (uncontrolled nuclear fission).
  • Strictly, the energy ΔE released in a chemical reaction can also be related to the mass defect, Δm = $ΔE/c^2$. However, for a chemical reaction involving nuclear reaction, the mass defect is much larger; although smaller for other types of chemical reaction.

Example 6.10: Examine Tables 6.1-6.3 and express (a) The energy required to break one bond in DNA in eV; (b) The kinetic energy of an air molecule (10$^{—21}$ J) in eV; (c) The daily intake of a human adult in kilocalories.

Solution: (a) Energy required to break one bond of DNA is
$$ \frac {10^{-20} \space J }{1.6× 10^{-19} \space J/eV } \simeq 0.06 \space eV$$
where the symbol ‘$ \simeq$ ’ stands for approximate.
Note 0.1 eV = 100 meV (100 millielectron volt).
(a) The kinetic energy of an air molecule is
$$ \frac {10^{-21} \space J }{1.6× 10^{-19} \space J/eV } \simeq 0.0062 \space eV $$

This is the same as 6.2 meV
(c) The average human consumption in a day is
$$ \frac {10^{7} \space J }{4.2× 10^{3} \space J/kcal } \simeq 2400 \space kcal$$
We point out a common misconception created by newspapers and magazines. They mention food values in calories and urge us to restrict diet intake to below 2400 calories. What they should be saying is kilocalories (kcal) and not calories. A person consuming 2400 calories a day will soon starve to death! 1 food calorie is 1 kcal.

Questions from sections 6.10 to 6.10.5:

  1. Explain the different forms into which potential energy gets transferred to; illustrate with the effect of frictional force acting between two bodies in contact.
  2. Describe endothermic and exothermic reactions.
  3. Arrive at the value of energy associated with 1kg of matter from Einstein’s mass energy equation.
  4. Describe nuclear fusion and fission reactions with an example for each type of reaction.
  5. What is mass defect (Δm)?

6.10.6 The Principle of Conservation of Energy

  • You may recollect how the total mechanical energy of a system is conserved if the forces doing work on it are conservative (that is, spring force, force of gravity and so on); while, in others, only a part of mechanical energy may get transformed into other forms such as heat, light or sound when conservative forces (such as, friction) act on it.
  • However, the total energy of an isolated system does not change, as long as we account for all forms of energy that results into. For instance, the mechanical energy being transformed into heat energy and kinetic energy when acted upon by a force account for the transformed energies.
  • Thus, the same is stated as law of conservation of energy (in several ways) as: “energy may be transformed from one form to another but the total energy of an isolated system remains constant.” “Energy can neither be created, nor destroyed.” “Since the universe as a whole may be viewed as an isolated system, the total energy of the universe is constant.” “If one part of the universe loses energy, another part must gain an equal amount of energy.” (the first two definitions are important from your exam point of view and you must remember them!)
  • Applications of the law: The concept of conservation and transformation of energy into various forms links together various branches of physics, chemistry and life sciences. It provides a unifying, lasting element in our scientific pursuits (or researches). From engineering point of view, all electronic, communication and mechanical devices rely on some forms of energy transformation.

6.11 Power

  • We say a person is physically fit if he not only climbs four floors of a building but climbs them fast. This could be related to the term, “power”. We can say that the person has greater power at climbing. Now, lets us try to define power in terms of physics.
  • Power is defined as the time rate at which work is done or energy is transferred.
  • The average power of a force is defined as the ratio of the work, W, to the total time taken, t as expressed below:
    $$ P_{av}= \frac {W}{t} $$
    The instantaneous power is defined as the limiting value of the average power as time
    interval approaches zero,
    $$ P = \frac {dW}{dt} \hspace{10mm} (6.21) $$
    The work dW done by a force F for a displacement dr is dW = F.dr. The instantaneous power can
    also be expressed as
    $$P=F. \frac {dr}{dt} $$
    $$ = F.v \hspace{10mm} (6.22) $$
    where v is the instantaneous velocity when the force is F.
    Power, like work and energy, is a scalar quantity. Its dimensions are $[ML^2T^{–3}]$. In the SI,its unit is called a watt (W). The watt is 1 J $s^{–1}$.The unit of power is named after James Watt,one of the innovators of the steam engine in the eighteenth century.
    There is another unit of power, namely the horse-power (hp)
    1 hp = 746 W
    This unit is still used to describe the output of automobiles, motorbikes, etc.
    We encounter the unit watt when we buy electrical goods such as bulbs, heaters and
    refrigerators. A 100 watt bulb which is on for 10 hours uses 1 kilowatt hour (kWh) of energy.
    100 (watt) × 10 (hour)
    = 1000 watt hour
    =1 kilowatt hour (kWh)
    $$= 10^3 (W) \times 3600 (s)$$
    $$= 3.6 \times 10^6 \space J $$
    Our electricity bills carry the energy consumption in units of kWh. Note that kWh is a unit of energy and not of power.

Example 6.11: An elevator can carry a maximum load of 1800 kg (elevator + passengers) is moving up with a constant speed of 2 m s$^{–1}$. The frictional force opposing the motion is 4000 N. Determine the minimum power delivered by the motor to the elevator in watts as well as in horse power.

Solution: The downward force on the elevator is

$$ F = m g + F_f= (1800 × 10) + 4000 = 22000 \space N $$

The motor must supply enough power to balance this force. Hence,

$$ P = F. v = 22000 × 2 = 44000 \space W = 59 \space hp $$

Questions from sections, 6.10 and 6.11:

  1. State and explain law of conservation of energy.
  2. List the applications of law of conservation of energy.
  3. Define power and average power.
  4. Arrive at the equation for instantaneous power, P in the form P= F.v (where, “v” is instantaneous velocity)

6.12 Collisions

  • In this section we shall apply the laws of momentum and energy conservation to collisions. As you know, several games such as billiards, marbles or carrom involve collision between objects.

We shall now study the collision of two masses under ideal conditions;

  • Consider two particles with masses, $m_1$ and $m_2$.
  • The particle, $m_1$ is moving with speed $v_{1i}$ (subscript ‘i’ stands initial), while $m_2$ is at rest.
  • When mass, $m_1$ collides with the stationary mass, $m_2$, the two particles set off in different directions as depicted in Fig. 6.10 below;

6.12.1 Elastic and Inelastic Collisions

Concept box:
A perfectly elastic collision is defined as one in which there is no loss of kinetic energy in the collision. An inelastic collision is one in which part of the kinetic energy is changed to some other form of energy in the collision.

In all collisions, the total linear momentum is conserved; that is, the initial momentum of the system is equal to the final momentum of the system.

One can argue this as follows;

  • When two objects collide, the mutual impulsive forces acting over the collision time, Δt, causes a change in their respective momenta (plural form of momentum) as expressed below:
    $$ \Delta p_1 = F_{12} \Delta t $$
    $$ \Delta p_2 =F_{21} \Delta t $$
    Where, $F_{12}$ is the force exerted on the first particle by the second particle. $F_{21}$ is likewise the force on the second particle by the first particle.
  • Now from Newton’s Third Law, $F_{12} = − F_{21}$. This implies
    $$Δp_1 + Δp_2 = 0 $$
    (The above conclusion is true no matter how the collision takes place. That is, even though the forces vary in a complex fashion during the collision time, Δt, the forces will still be equal and opposite.)
  • Since the third law is true at every instant, the total impulse on the first object is equal and opposite of the impulse on the second.
  • However, the total kinetic energy of the system is not necessarily conserved. This is due to the loss of energy during impact and deformation, which may generate heat and sound. Thus, part of the initial kinetic energy is transformed into other forms of energy.
  • To get a clearer picture of how collision occurs between bodies, imagine the two masses to be connected by a compressed spring whenever they collide. If the two objects get deflected in such a way that the (imaginary) spring connecting the two bodies goes back to its original state, then the energy is said to be conserved during the collision. The final and initial kinetic energies would be the same; although it is different during the collision time, Δt. Such a collision is called an elastic collision.
  • On the other hand, the deformation (recollect how a rolling body get slightly deformed when it comes in contact with another) and the two bodies could move together even after the collision. Such a collision in which the two particles remain together after collision is called a completely inelastic collision.
  • The intermediate case where the “deformation is partly relieved (that is, the two bodies begin to move apart, but may not completely separate)” and some of the initial kinetic energy is lost (in other forms such as sound and heat) is more common and is appropriately called an inelastic collision.

6.12.2 Collisions in One Dimension

Consider a completely inelastic collision in one dimension. Then, in Fig. 6.10,
$$ θ1= θ_2=0 $$ $$ m_1v{1i} =(m_1+m_2)v_f \space (momentum \space conservation ) $$

$$ v_f =\frac {m_1}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i} \hspace{10mm} (6.23) $$

The loss in kinetic energy on collision is
$$ \Delta K = \frac {1}{2} m_1v^2_{1i}-\frac {1}{2}(m_1+m_2)v^2_f $$
$$ \frac {1}{2}m_1v^2_{1i}- \frac {1}{2} \frac {m^2_1}{m_1+m_2}v^2_{if} \hspace{10mm} [using \space Eq. (6.23)] $$

$$ = \frac {1}{2} m_1v^2_{1i} \bigg[ 1- \frac {m_1}{m_1+m_2} \bigg] $$
$$ = \frac {1}{2} \frac {m_1m_2}{m_1+m_2}v^2_{1i} $$

which is a positive quantity as expected.

Consider next an elastic collision. Using the above nomenclature with $θ_ 1 = θ 2$ = 0, the momentum and kinetic energy conservation equations are $$ m_1v{1i}=m_1v_{1f}+m_2v_{2f} \hspace{10mm} (6.24) $$

$$m_1v^2_{1i}=m_1v^2_{1f}+m_2v^2_{2f} \hspace{10mm} (6.25) $$

From Eqs. (6.24) and (6.25) it follows that,

$$m_1v_{1i}(v_{2f}-v_{1i})=m_1v_{1f}(v_{2f}-v_{1f}) $$

$$or,v_{2f}(v_{1i}-v_{1f})=v^2_{1i}-v^2_{1f} $$
$$=(v_{1i}-v_{1f})( v_{1i}+v_{1f}) $$

Hence, ∴$v_{2f} =v_{1i} +v_{1f} $ (6.26)

Substituting this in Eq. (6.24), we obtain

$$ v_{1f}= \frac {(m_1-m_2)}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i} \hspace{10mm} (6.27) $$
$$ and \space v_{2f} = \frac {2m_1v_{1i}}{m_1+m_2} \hspace{10mm} (6.28) $$
Thus, the ‘unknowns’ {$v_{1f}, v_{2f}$} are obtained in terms of the ‘knowns’ {$m_1, m_2, v_{1i}$}. Special cases of our analysis are interesting.

Case I : If the two masses are equal
$$ v_{1f} = 0$$
$$ v_{2f} = v_{1i} $$
The first mass comes to rest and pushes off the second mass with its initial speed on collision.

Case II : If one mass dominates, e.g. $m_2 > > m_1$
$$ v_{1f} \simeq – v_{1i} \hspace{10mm} v_{2f} \simeq 0 $$
The heavier mass is undisturbed while the lighter mass reverses its velocity.

Example 6.12: Slowing down of neutrons: In a nuclear reactor a neutron of high speed (typically 10$^7$ m s$^{–1}$) must be slowed to 10$^3$ m s$^{–1}$ so that it can have a high probability of interacting with isotope $ \ce {^{235}{92}U}$ and causing it to fission. Show that a neutron can lose most of its kinetic energy in an elastic collision with a light nuclei like deuterium or carbon which has a mass of only a few times the neutron mass. The material making up the light nuclei, usually heavy water ($D_2O$) or graphite, is called a moderator.

Solution: The initial kinetic energy of the neutron is $$ K{1i}= \frac {1}{ 2} m_1v^2_{1i} $$
while its final kinetic energy from Eq. (6.27)
$$ K_{1f}= \frac {1}{ 2} m_1v^2_{1f} = \frac {1}{2} m_1 \bigg( \frac {m_1-m_2}{m_1+m_2 }\bigg)^2 v_{1i}^2 $$
The fractional kinetic energy lost is
$$ f_1 = \frac { K_{1f}}{ K_{1i}}=\bigg( \frac {m_1-m_2}{m_1+m_2 }\bigg)^2 $$
while the fractional kinetic energy gained by the moderating nuclei $K_{2f} /K_{1i}$ is
$f_2 = 1 – f_1$ (elastic collision)
$$ = \frac {4m_1m_2}{(m_1+m_2)^2} $$

One can also verify this result by substituting from Eq. (6.28).

For deuterium $m_2 = 2m_1$ and we obtain $f_1$ = 1/9 while $f_2$ = 8/9. Almost 90% of the neutron’s energy is transferred to deuterium. For carbon $f_1$ = 71.6% and $f_2$ = 28.4%. In practice, however, this number is smaller since head-on collisions are rare.

6.12.3 Collisions in Two Dimensions

  • Fig. 6.10 also depicts the collision of a moving mass $m_1$, with the stationary mass $m_2$. Linear momentum is conserved in such a collision.
  • Since momentum is a vector, it can be expressed by three equations in the three directions: x, y and z.
  • Let the final velocity of the particles, $m_1$ and $m_2$ be in the x-y plane.
  • Since the linear momentum is conserved in the z-direction, we can say that the entire collision is in the x-y plane.

The x- and y-component equations are;
$$m_1v_{1i} = m_1v_{1f} cos\space θ 1 + m_2v{2f} \space cos θ_2 ……… (6.29)$$

$$0 = m_1v_{1f} sin \space θ1 – m_2v{2f} sin \space θ_2 ……….. (6.30) $$

  • We will be given the values of $m_1$, $m_2$, $v_{1i}$ in most situations with four unknowns: $v_{1f}$, $v_{2f}, θ_1$ and $θ_2$, and we have only two equations as above (6.29 and 6.30).
  • If $θ 1 = θ 2$ = 0, we regain equation, (6.24) for one dimensional collision.
  • Further, if the collision is elastic, as you know, the initial kinetic energy will be equal to final kinetic energy and the equation obtained can thus be expressed as:
    $$ \frac {1}{2}m_1v^2_{1i}= \frac {1}{2}m_1v^2_{1f}+\frac {1}{2}m_2v^2_{2f} ………..(6.31)$$
  • Although, we obtain an additional equation, that still leaves us one equation short. Thus, at least one of the four unknowns, say $θ_1$, must be made known for the problem to be solvable.
    For example, $θ_1$ can be determined by moving a detector in an angular fashion from the x to the y axis.
  • Therefore, given: $m_1$, $m_2, v_{1i}, θ1$, we can determine: $v{1f}, v_{2f}, θ2$ from equations (6.29)-(6.31).

Example 6.13: Consider the collision depicted in Fig. 6.10 to be between two billiard balls with equal masses $m_1 = m_2$. The first ball is called the cue while the second ball is called the target. The billiard player wants to ‘sink’ the target ball in a corner pocket, which is at an angle $θ_2$ = 37°. Assume that the collision is elastic and that friction and rotational motion are not important. Obtain $θ 1$ .

Solution: From momentum conservation, since the masses are equal
$$ v_{1i} = v_{1f} + v_{2f} $$
$$ or \space v_{1i}^2 = ( v_{1f} + v_{2f}).( v_{1f} + v_{2f}) $$
$$ = v_{1f}^2 + v_{2f}^2 +2v_{1f}.v_{2f} $$
$$ ={ v_{1f}^2 + v_{2f}^2 + 2v_{1f}v_{2f} \space cos \space (θ1 + 37^o) } \hspace{10mm} (6.32) $$ Since the collision is elastic and$ m_1 = m_2$ it follows from conservation of kinetic energy that $$ v{1i}^2 = v_{1f}^2 + v_{2f}^2 \hspace{10mm} (6.33) $$
Comparing Eqs. (6.32) and (6.33), we get
$$ cos \space (θ_1 + 37°) = 0 $$
$$ or \space θ_1 + 37° = 90° $$
Thus, $ θ_1 = 53° $

This proves the following result : when two equal masses undergo a glancing elastic collision with one of them at rest, after the collision, they will move at right angles to each other.

  • To make things simpler, we consider spherical masses with smooth surfaces, and assume that collision takes place only when the bodies touch each other as it does in the games of marbles, carrom and billiards.
  • In our everyday world, collisions take place only when two bodies touch each other.
  • But consider a comet coming from far distances to the sun or earth; (or) alpha particle coming towards a nucleus and going away in some direction. In such cases, we have to deal with forces involving action at a distance. Such an event is called scattering.
  • The velocities and directions in which the two particles go away depend on their initial velocities as well as the type of interaction between them, their masses, shapes and sizes.

Questions from the sections, 6.12 to 6.12.3:

1. Describe elastic and inelastic collisions.

2. Arrive at the equations for final velocities of two bodies that undergo collision (in one-dimension), in the form:

$$ v_{1f} = \frac {(m_1-m_2)}{m_1+m_2}v_{1i} $$

$$ v_{2f} = \frac {2m_1v_{1i}}{m_1+m_2} $$