Hello

Chapter 12 – Thermodynamics – 11th Physics

37โ€“56 minutes

12.0 Preview:

As you will see, the chapter is a sequel of the previous. Thus, you could expect topics that revolve around thermodynamics as the study of heat and temperature and the conversion of heat to other forms of energy and vice versa. We shall begin by defining the term, thermal equilibrium in many contexts: It means that the net external forces on the system and torque are zero; if microscopic variables like pressure, temperature, volume do not change in time for a system; if the variables of the enclosed system become same as that of the external surroundings and so on.

We shall start with the zeroth law which states that two systems in thermal equilibrium with a third system separately are in thermal equilibrium with each other. We shall study Internal energy in some detail, which is simply the sum of kinetic energies and potential energies of the particles of the system in a frame of reference, relative to which the centre of mass of the system is at rest; then, work doneโ€” Work is said to be done if there is a transfer of energy between a system and its surroundings, under the influence of forces but without difference of temperatures;

We shall state the first law of thermodynamics as, โ€œThe amount of heat supplied to a system as being equal to the sum of increase in its internal energy and the external work done by the system against its surroundingsโ€; work done by the system against a constant pressure P is mathematically formulated as: ฮ”W = P ฮ”V; Heat capacity is defined as: S = ฮ”Q/ ฮ”T and specific heat capacity is defined by s = S/m.

State variables will then be introduced to you. The values of macroscopic variables used to describe the state of equilibrium of a thermodynamic system are called state variables (like, temperature, pressure and so on); the connection between the various state variables is called the equation of state. For instance, we can establish for an ideal gas, the equation of state as: P V = ฮผ R T

You would be interested to study about an idealised process in which, at every stage, the system is in equilibrium state. Such a process in real is, infinitely slow-hence the name quasi-static. We shall consequently run through the types of quasi-static processesโ€” A process in which the temperature of the system is kept fixed throughout is called an isothermal process. In isobaric processes, the pressure is constant while in isochoric processes the volume is constant. Finally, if the system is insulated from the surroundings and no heat flows between the system and the surroundings, the process is adiabatic. Cyclic process, as the process in which, the system returns to its initial state after undergoing a series of changes in its state variables.

Further, we will learn about working of a heat engine, a device by which a system is made to undergo a cyclic process that results in conversion of heat to work; whose efficiency is defined by the ratio of amount of heat converted into mechanical work to the amount of heat absorbed from the source.

We shall also look at the working of a heat pump and a refrigerator, whose principles are nearly the same but serve different purposes; if the purpose is to cool a portion of space, like the inside of a chamber, and higher temperature reservoir is surrounding, we call the device a refrigerator; if the idea is to pump heat into a portion of space, say, to heat the room in a building when the outside environment is cold, the device is called a heat pump.

Then, the second law of thermodynamics will be dealt with, which simply states that, efficiency of a heat engine can never be unity. We will also study Kelvin-Planck statement and Clausiusโ€™ statement along the same lines.

We will then switch to two special types of processes: Reversible and Irreversible processes. Reversible process is the process which can be made to proceed in two opposite directions with same effort in both directions, so that the system and the surroundings pass through exactly the same intermediate states as in the direct process (or the forward process) and Irreversible process as the vice versa.

We shall end the discussion with the most interesting topic, the working of a Carnotโ€™s engine, since it is the most efficient one! The principle of working of a Carnotโ€™s engine is based on the Carnotโ€™s cycle in which Carnot engine is taken through a cycle of operations known as the Carnot cycle. In this, all the processes are quasi-static.

12.1 Introduction:

Thermodynamics is the branch of physics that deals with the concepts of heat and temperature and the conversion of heat into other forms of energy and vice versa.

In this chapter, we shall study laws that govern thermal energy. We shall study the processes where work is converted into heat and vice versa. In winter, when we rub our palms together, we feel warmer; here work done in rubbing produces the โ€˜heatโ€™. Conversely, in a steam engine, the โ€˜heatโ€™ of the steam is used to do useful work in moving the pistons, which in turn rotate the wheels of the train.

We will see how heat flows from a body at higher temperature to a body at lower temperature until the temperatures of the two bodies equalize.

12.2 Thermal Equilibrium

  • Equilibrium in mechanics means that the net external force and torque on a system are zero.
  • The term equilibrium is used in many contexts: we say that, the state of a system is in equilibrium state if the macroscopic variables that characterise the system do not change in time. For example, a gas inside a closed rigid container completely insulated from its surroundings, with fixed values of pressure, volume, temperature, mass and composition that does not change with time is in a state of thermodynamic equilibrium.
  • In general, whether or not a system is in a state of equilibrium depends on the surroundings and the nature of the wall that separates the system from the surroundings.
  • A system is said to be in thermal equilibrium if the temperature of every part of the system is same as that of its surroundings.
    To understand a system in equilibrium, we shall consider the following setups,
  • Let us consider two gases A and B, occupying two different containers. We know experimentally that, pressure and volume of a given mass of gas can be chosen to be its two independent variables. Let the pressure and volume of the gases be ($P_A, V_A$) and ($P_B, V_B$) respectively.
  • Suppose we keep two systems close to each other and separate them by an adiabatic wall, an insulating wall (can be movable) that does not allow flow of energy (heat) from one to another.
  • The systems are insulated from the rest of the surroundings by another adiabatic wall. The situation is shown schematically in Figure 12.1 (a).

Figure 12.1 (a) Systems A and B (two gases) separated by an adiabatic wall โ€“ an insulating wall that does not allow flow of heat. (b) The same systems A and B separated by a diathermic wall โ€“ a conducting wall that allows heat to flow from one to another. In
this case, thermal equilibrium is attained in due course.

  • In this case, it is found that, any possible pair of values, $(P_A, V_A)$ will be in equilibrium with any possible pair of values $(P_B, V_B)$ (In other words, corresponding values of pressure and volume will be equal) at all times.
  • Next, suppose that the adiabatic wall is replaced by a diathermic wallโ€“ a conducting wall that allows energy flow (heat) from one chamber to another. It is then found that, the macroscopic variables of the systems A and B change spontaneously until both the systems attain equilibrium states. After that, there is no change in their states. The situation is shown in Figure 12.1(b).
  • The pressure and volume of the two gases change to $(P_Bโ€ฒ, V_Bโ€ฒ)$ and $(P_Aโ€ฒ, V_Aโ€ฒ)$; such that, the new states of A and B are in equilibrium with each other (Both the variables need not change. It depends on the constraints. For instance, if the gases are in containers of fixed volume, only the pressures of the gases would change to achieve thermal equilibrium.)
  • There is no more energy flow from one to another once equilibrium is achieved. We then say that, the system A is in thermal equilibrium with the system B.
  • In thermal equilibrium, the temperatures of the two systems are equal. We shall study about this in much detail in the following section.

Questions from sections 12.1 and 12.2:

  1. Define Thermodynamics.
  2. What is equilibrium?
  3. Explain how equilibrium is achieved when two systems are separated by an adiabatic wall and when separated by a diathermic wall.

12.3 Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics

Definition box:
Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics: It states that, two systems in thermal equilibrium with a third system separately are in thermal equilibrium with each other.

R.H. Fowler formulated this law in 1931 long after the first and second Laws of thermodynamics were stated and so numbered.

  • Let us imagine two systems, A and B, separated by an adiabatic wall, while each is in contact with a third system C through a conducting wall [Figure 12.2(a) below]. The states of the systems (i.e., their macroscopic variables) will change until both A and B is at thermal equilibrium with C.

Figure 12.2 (a) Systems A and B are separated by an adiabatic wall, while each is in contact with a third system C via a conducting wall. (b) The adiabatic wall between A and B is replaced by a conducting wall, while C is insulated from A and B by an adiabatic wall.

  • Now, suppose that the adiabatic wall between A and B is replaced by a conducting wall and C is insulated from A and B by an adiabatic wall [Figure 12.2(b) below], it is found that, the states of A and B do not change further. That is, they are found to be in thermal equilibrium with each other.
  • This observation forms the basis of the Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics.
  • The Zeroth Law clearly suggests that, when two systems, A and B, are in thermal equilibrium, there must be a physical quantity that has the same value for both. This thermodynamic variable, whose value is equal for two systems in thermal equilibrium, is called temperature (T). Thus, if A and B are separately in equilibrium with C, $T_A = T_C$ and $T_B = T_C$. This implies that, $T_A = T_B$ that is, the systems A and B are also in thermal equilibrium. We have thus arrived at the concept of temperature via the Zeroth Law.
  • Now, we will learn how to assign numerical values to temperatures of different bodies. In other words, how do we construct a scale of temperature? We shall turn to the next section to answer this.

Questions for section 12.3:

1. Define Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics?

12.4 Heat, Internal Energy and Work

Temperature is a marker of the โ€˜hotnessโ€™ of a body. It determines the direction of flow of heat when two bodies are placed in thermal contact. Heat flows from the body at a higher temperature to the one at lower temperature. The flow stops when the temperatures equalise; the two bodies are then in thermal equilibrium.

Internal energy

  • We know that, every bulk system consists of a large number of molecules.
  • Internal energy is simply the sum of the kinetic energies and potential energies of the particles of the system in a frame of reference, relative to which the centre of mass of the system is at rest. The internal energy of the system is denoted by U.
  • Internal energy of a system depends on state of the system. Hence, it is a state variable.
  • Internal energy of a system does not depend on the path followed by a system between two states.
  • In the case of an ideal gas, intermolecular forces are zero. As a result, the potential energy of its molecules is zero. Hence, internal energy of ideal gas is the sum of kinetic energies of the random motion of molecules of the gas. This motion is not only translational motion from one point to another in the volume of the container; it also includes rotational and vibrational motion of the molecules (as shown in Figure 12.3 below).

Figure 12.3 (a) Internal energy U of a gas is the sum of the kinetic and potential energies of its molecules when the box is at rest. Kinetic energy due to various types of motion
(translational, rotational, vibrational) is to be included in U. (b) If the same box is
moving as a whole with some velocity, the kinetic energy of the box is not to be included in U.

  • In the case of an ideal gas, internal energy depends only on temperature and does not depend on pressure and volume.
  • In the case of a real gas, internal energy depends on both temperature and volume.
  • Two general modes of energy transfer resulting in the change of internal energy of a system are achieved by,
    a) Supplying heat to the system
    b) Doing some mechanical work on the system.
    This is illustrated through the example of a cylinder with a movable piston,

Figure 12.4 Heat and work are two distinct modes of energy transfer to a system that results in change in its internal energy. (a) Heat is energy transfer due to temperature difference between the system and the surroundings. (b) Work is energy transfer
brought about by means (e.g. moving the piston by raising or lowering some weight
connected to it) that do not involve such a temperature difference.

  • One way is to put the cylinder in contact with a body at a higher temperature than that of the gas. The temperature difference will cause a flow of energy (heat) from the hotter body to the gas, thus increasing the internal energy of the gas.
  • The other way is to push the piston down that is, to do work on the system, which again results in increasing the internal energy of the gas.
  • Of course, both these things could happen in the reverse direction. With surroundings at a lower temperature, heat would flow from the gas to the surroundings. Likewise, the gas could push the piston up and do work on the surroundings.
  • In short, heat and work are two different modes of altering the state of a thermodynamic system and changing its internal energy. This brings us to the definition of work done.
Definition box:
External work: Work is said to be done if there is a transfer of energy between a system and its surroundings, under the influence of forces but without difference of temperatures.

Questions for section 12.4:

  1. When do you say that two bodies are in thermal equilibrium?
  2. What is internal energy?
  3. By what means can we change the internal energy of a system? Explain with the illustration of a movable piston in a cylinder.
  4. When is work said to be done?

12.5 First Law of Thermodynamics

Definition box:  
The first law of thermodynamics states that, โ€œThe amount of heat supplied to a system is equal to the sum of increase in its internal energy and the external work done by the system against its surroundings.โ€
  • We have seen that, the internal energy U of a system can change through two modes of energy transfer: heat and work. Let,
    ฮ”Q = Heat supplied to the system by the surroundings
    ฮ”W = Work done by the system on the surroundings
    ฮ”U = Change in internal energy of the system
    The general principle of conservation of energy then implies that,
    ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + ฮ”W โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ. (12.1)
    This equation is nothing but the First law of thermodynamics. (It is simply the general law of conservation of energy applied to any system in which the energy transfer from or to the surroundings is taken into account.)
  • Alternatively, we can write equation 12.1 as:

ฮ”Q โ€“ ฮ”W = ฮ”U โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.. (12.2)

  • Now, the system may go from an initial state to the final state in a number of ways,
    ๏‚ง For example, to change the state of a gas from $(P_1, V_1)$ to $(P_2, V_2)$, we can first change the volume of the gas from $V_1$ to $V_2$, keeping its pressure constant. That is, we can first change volume and have: $(P_1, V_2)$ and then change the pressure of the gas from $P_1$ to $P_2$, keeping volume constant, to take the gas to $(P_2, V_2)$.
    ๏‚ง Alternatively, we can first keep the volume constant and then keep the pressure constant. Since U is a state variable, ฮ”U depends only on the initial and final states and not on the path taken by the gas to go from one to the other. However, ฮ”Q and ฮ”W will, in general, depend on the path taken to go from the initial to final states.
  • From the First Law of Thermodynamics, Equation (12.2), it is clear that ฮ”Q โ€“ ฮ”W is path independent. This shows that, if a system is taken through a process in which ฮ”U = 0, heat supplied to the system is used up entirely by the system in doing work on the environment. If the system is a gas in a cylinder with a movable piston, the gas, in moving the piston does work.
  • Since, force is pressure times area, and area times displacement is volume, work done by the system against a constant pressure P is,
    ฮ”W = P ฮ”V
    Where, ฮ”V is the change in volume of the gas.
    Thus, for this case, Equation (12.1) gives,
    ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + P ฮ”V โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ. (12.3)

As an application of Equation (12.3), consider the following example:

Example box:  
Find the change in internal energy for 1 g of water when we go from its liquid to vapour phase. The measured latent heat of water is 2256 J/g. that is, for 1 g of water, ฮ”Q = 2256 J. At atmospheric pressure, 1 g of water has a volume 1 $cm^3$ in liquid phase and 1671 $cm^3$ in vapour phase. Therefore,
$$ \Delta W = P(V_g โ€“ V_1)=1.013 \times 10^5 \times (1670) \times 10^{-6} = 169.2 \space J $$
Equation (12.3) then gives
$$ \Delta U =2256-169.2=2086.8 \space J$$
We see that, most of the heat goes to increase the internal energy of water in transition from the liquid to the vapour phase.

12.6 Specific Heat Capacity

Suppose that an amount of heat, ฮ”Q is supplied to a substance and changes its temperature from T to T + ฮ”T. We define heat capacity (from previous chapter) of the substance to be,

S = ฮ”Q/ ฮ”Tโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.. (12.4)

We expect ฮ”Q and therefore, heat capacity, S to be proportional to the mass of the substance. (Further, it could also depend on the temperature. That is, a different amount of heat may be needed for a unit rise in temperature at different temperatures). To define a constant characteristic of the substance and independent of its amount, we divide S by the mass of the substance, m in kg:

$$ s = \frac {s}{m} = \bigg( \frac {1}{m} \bigg) \bigg( \frac { \Delta Q}{\Delta t } \bigg) โ€ฆ..(12.5)$$

โ€œsโ€ is known as the specific heat capacity of the substance. It depends on the nature of the substance and its temperature.

Note box: The unit of specific heat capacity is J $kg^{โ€“1}$ $K^{โ€“1}$.

If the amount of substance is specified in terms of moles ฮผ (instead of mass m in kg), we can define heat capacity per mole of the substance by,

$$ C=\frac {S}{ฮผ}= \bigg( \frac {1}{ฮผ} \bigg) \bigg( \frac {Q}{dT} \bigg) โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ.. (12.6)$$

C is known as molar specific heat capacity of the substance.

Note box:
1. Like โ€œsโ€, C is independent of the amount of substance.
2. C depends on the nature of the substance, its temperature and the conditions under which heat is supplied.
3. The unit of C is J $mo1^{โ€“1}$ $K^{โ€“1}$.

Now, let us consider a solid of N atoms, each vibrating about its mean position. An oscillator in one dimension has average energy of 2 ร— ยฝ $k_{BT} = k_{BT}$. In three dimensions, the average energy is 3 $k_{BT}$. For a mole of a solid, the total energy is
$$ U = 3 \space k_BT ร— N_A = 3 \space RT $$
Now, at constant pressure, ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + P ฮ”V โ‰…ฮ”U, since for a solid ฮ”V is negligible. Therefore,
$$ C = \frac {\Delta Q}{\Delta T} = \frac {\Delta U}{\Delta T}=3R โ€ฆโ€ฆ(12.7)$$

Table 12.1 lists measured specific and molar heat capacities of solids at atmospheric pressure and ordinary room temperature.

Table 12.1 shows the experimentally measured values, which generally agrees with predicted value 3R at ordinary temperatures. (Carbon is an exception.) The value is also not in accord with 3R at low temperatures.

Specific heat capacity of water

  • The old unit of heat was calorie. One calorie was in the earlier days, defined as the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of 1g of water by 1ยฐC.
  • With more precise measurements, it was found that the specific heat of water varies slightly with temperature. Figure 12.5 shows this variation in the temperature range from 0 to 100 ยฐC.
  • For a precise definition of calorie, it was, therefore, necessary to specify the unit temperature interval.

Definition box:

One calorie is defined to be the amount of heat required to raise the temperature of 1g of water from 14.5 ยฐC to 15.5 ยฐC.

Figure 12.5 Variation of specific heat capacity of water with temperature.
Note box:
1. Since, heat is a form of energy; we use the unit joule, J.
2. In SI units, the specific heat capacity of water is 4186 J $kg^{โ€“1}$ $K^{โ€“1}$ i.e. 4.186 J $g^{โ€“1}$  $K^{โ€“1}$. 1. State and explain the first law of thermodynamics with relevant equations

Specific heat capacities of gases

  • For gases, we can define two specific heats: specific heat capacity at constant volume and specific heat capacity at constant pressure. For an ideal gas, we have a simple relation that relate the two,
    $$ C_p-C_v=Rโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ. (12.8)$$

The above equation is known as Meyerโ€™s Equation.

Consider one mole of a perfect gas

From I law of thermodynamics, ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + P ฮ”V

Where ฮ”Q=Heat supplied to the system.

ฮ”U=Change in internal energy of the system.

P ฮ”V=Work done by the system against constant pressure.

If heat ฮ”Q is adsorbed by the system at constant volume, ฮ”V=0

Then $ \bigg( \frac { \Delta Q }{\Delta T} \bigg)_v = \bigg( \frac { \Delta U}{\Delta T} \bigg)_v = \frac { \Delta U}{ \Delta T } $

Subscript V is dropped since U depends only on the temperature of the gas

But we know $ C_v = \bigg( \frac { \Delta Q }{\Delta T} \bigg)_v $, where $C_v$ is the molar specific heat capacity of the gas at constant volume
$$ \therefore C_v = \frac {\Delta U}{ \Delta T} โ€ฆโ€ฆ(2) $$

If heat ฮ”Q is adsorbed by the system at constant pressure,

$$ \bigg( \frac { \Delta Q }{\Delta T} \bigg)_p = \bigg( \frac { \Delta U}{\Delta T} \bigg)_p + P \bigg( \frac {\Delta V}{\Delta T} \bigg)_p $$
$$ \implies \frac { \Delta Q }{\Delta T} = \frac { \Delta U}{\Delta T} + P \frac {\Delta V}{\Delta T} $$

But we know $C_p = \bigg( \frac {\Delta Q}{\Delta T} \bigg)_p โ€ฆ.(3)$

Where $C_p$ is the molar specific heat capacity of the gas at constant pressure.
$$ \therefore C_p = \frac {\Delta U}{\Delta T}+ P \frac {\Delta V}{\Delta T} $$
$$ \implies C_p=C_v+ P \frac {\Delta V}{\Delta T} โ€ฆ.(4)$$

For one mole of an ideal gas,PV=RT

$$ \implies P \frac {\Delta V}{\Delta T}= R โ€ฆ(5) $$

Substituting (5) in (4),

$$ C_p =C_v + R $$
$$ \implies C_p โ€“ C_v = R $$

Questions from sections 12.5 and 12.6:

  1. State and explain the first law of thermodynamics.
  2. Define heat capacity and specific heat capacity of a substance, with equations.
  3. What is the SI Unit of heat capacity?
  4. Define heat capacity per mole of the substance with the equation.
  5. Arrive at the equation for Specific heat capacity for a solid; in the form C= 3R.
  6. Define one calorie.
  7. What is the specific heat capacity of water?
  8. Arrive at the relationship between specific heat capacity at constant volume and at constant pressure for an ideal gas.

12.7 Thermodynamic State Variables and Equation of State

Definition box:
The values of macroscopic variables used to describe the state of equilibrium of a thermodynamic system are called state variables.

Example box:

  • For example, an equilibrium state of a gas is completely specified by the values of pressure, volume, temperature, and mass (and composition in case of a mixture of gases).
  • A thermodynamic system is not always in equilibrium. For example, a gas allowed to expand freely against vacuum is not in an equilibrium state [Figure 12.6(a)]. During the rapid expansion, pressure may vary.

Figure 12.6 (a) The partition in the box is suddenly removed leading to free expansion of the gas. (b) A mixture of gases undergoing an explosive chemical reaction. In both situations, the gas is not in equilibrium and cannot be described by state variables.

  • Similarly, a mixture of gases undergoing an explosive chemical reaction (for example, a mixture of petrol vapour and air when ignited by a spark) is not in an equilibrium state. Again, its temperature and pressure are not uniform [Fig. 12.6(b)]. Eventually, the gas attains a uniform temperature and pressure and comes to thermal and mechanical equilibrium (with its surroundings).

The connection between the various state variables is called the equation of state. For example, for an ideal gas, the equation of state is the ideal gas relation,
P V = ฮผ R T

  • For a fixed amount of the gas, given by ฮผ, there are only two independent variables (that is, only two quantities vary at a time), say P and V or T and V.
  • The pressure-volume curve for a fixed temperature is called, an isotherm.
  • The thermodynamic state variables are of two kinds: extensive and intensive. Extensive variables like mass and volume indicate the size of the system. Intensive variables such as pressure and temperature do not indicate size.
  • To decide which variable is extensive and which intensive, let us picture a relevant system in equilibrium, and imagine that it is divided into two equal parts. The variables that remain unchanged for each part, upon division are intensive. The variables whose values get halved in each part are extensive.
  • It is easily seen, for example, that internal energy U, volume V, total mass M are extensive variables since they get halved when the system is divided in two. Pressure P, temperature T, and density ฯ are intensive variables. It is a good practice to check the consistency of thermodynamic equations using this classification of variables. For example, in the following equation,
    ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + P ฮ”V, quantities on both sides are extensive.
Note box:
The product of an intensive variable like P and an extensive quantity ฮ”V is extensive.

Questions for section 12.7:

  1. Define:
    a) State Variable
    b) Isotherm
  2. Give an example for equation of a state.
  3. What are intensive and extensive variables? Explain with an example.

12.8 Thermodynamic Processes

12.8.1 Quasi-static process

  • Let us consider a gas in thermal and mechanical equilibrium with its surroundings. Then, we know that, the pressure of the gas equals the external pressure and its temperature is the same as that of its surroundings.
  • When external pressure is suddenly reduced, say, by lifting the weight on the movable piston in the container. The piston will accelerate outward. During the process, the gas passes through states that are not equilibrium states (that is, their state variables change and thus become unequal to those of the surroundings). Thus, the non-equilibrium states do not have well-defined pressure and temperature.
  • In the same way, when a finite temperature difference exists between the gas and its surroundings, there will be a rapid exchange of heat; during which, the gas will pass through non-equilibrium states. (Gradually however, the gas will settle to an equilibrium state with well-defined temperature and pressure equal to those of the surroundings).
  • The free expansion of a gas in vacuum and a mixture of gases undergoing an explosive chemical reaction are examples where the system goes through non-equilibrium states.
  • Non-equilibrium states of a system are difficult to deal with. It is therefore, convenient to imagine an idealised process in which, at every stage, the system is in equilibrium state. Such a process in real is, infinitely slow-hence the name quasi-static (meaning nearly static). The system changes its variables (P, T, V) so slowly that it remains in thermal and mechanical equilibrium with its surroundings throughout. In a quasi-static process, at every stage, the difference in the pressure of the system and the external pressure is infinitesimally small. The same is true of the temperature difference between the system and its surroundings.
  • To achieve this, we take a gas from the state (P, T) to another state (P โ€ฒ, T โ€ฒ) via a quasi-static process, wherein we change the external pressure by a very small amount, allow the system to equalise its pressure with that of the surroundings and continue the process infinitely slowly until the system achieves the pressure Pโ€ฒ.
  • Similarly, to change the temperature, we introduce an infinitesimally small temperature difference between the system and the surrounding reservoirs and by choosing surrounding reservoirs of progressively different temperatures, T to T โ€ฒ, the system achieves the temperature T โ€ฒ.

Figure 12.7 In a quasi-static process, the temperature of the surrounding reservoir and the external pressure differ only infinitesimally from the temperature and pressure of the system.

We shall now introduce some of the Quasi-static processes;

  • A process in which the temperature of the system is kept fixed throughout is called an isothermal process.
    For example, the expansion of a gas in a metallic cylinder placed in a large reservoir of fixed temperature is an example of an isothermal process. (Heat transferred from the reservoir to the system does not materially affect the temperature of the reservoir, because of its very large heat capacity.)
  • In isobaric processes the pressure is constant while in isochoric processes the volume is constant.
  • Finally, if the system is insulated from the surroundings and no heat flows between the system and the surroundings, the process is adiabatic. The definitions of these special processes are summarised in Table. 12.2.

Isothermal process

Definition box:
The process in which temperature is kept constant is called an isothermal process.

For an isothermal process (T fixed), the ideal gas equation gives PV = constant. That is, pressure of a given mass of gas varies inversely as its volume. This is nothing but Boyleโ€™s Law.

Suppose, an ideal gas goes isothermally with constant temperature, T from its initial state: $(P_1, V_1)$ to the final state: $(P_2, V_2)$. At any intermediate stage, with pressure P and volume change from V to V + ฮ”V (ฮ”V being small),

ฮ”W = P ฮ” V

Where, ฮ”W is work done against external pressure.

Taking (ฮ”V โ†’ 0) and summing the quantity ฮ”W over the entire process,

$$ W = \int_{V_1}^{V_2} P \space dV $$

$$ \therefore W = ยต RT \int_{V_1}^{V_2} \frac {dv}{V}= ยตRT ln \frac {V_2}{V_1} dV โ€ฆ. .(12.12)$$

Note box:  
From Equation (12.12), when $V_2> V1_, W > 0$; and when $V_2 < V_1$, W < 0. That is, in an isothermal expansion, the gas absorbs heat and does work while in an isothermal compression, work is done on the gas by the environment and heat is released. 
Figure 12.8 P-V curves for isothermal and adiabatic processes of an ideal gas.

Adiabatic process

Definition box:
Adiabatic process: An adiabatic process is the process in which the system is insulated from the surroundings and heat absorbed or released is zero.
  • From Equation (12.1), we see that work done by the gas results in decrease in its internal energy (and hence its temperature for an ideal gas).
    $$ P V^ ฮณ = constant โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ (12.13)$$
    Where, ฮณ is the ratio of specific heat at constant pressure to the specific heat at constant volume.
    $$ ฮณ = \frac {C_p}{C_v} $$
    Thus if an ideal gas undergoes a change in its state adiabatically from ($P_1, V_1)$ to ($P_2, V_2$) :
    $$ P_1 V_1^ฮณ = P_2 V_2^ฮณ โ€ฆโ€ฆ. (12.14)$$
  • Figure12.8 shows the P-V curves of an ideal gas for two adiabatic processes connecting two isotherms.
  • We can calculate, as before, the work done in an adiabatic change of an ideal gas from the state ($P_1, V_1, T_1$) to the state ($P_2, V_2, T_2$);
    $$ W = \int_{V_1}^{V_2} P \space dV=\int_{V_1}^{V_2} \frac {k}{V^ ฮณ}dV $$ (Using equation of state $PV ฮณ$=constant (k))
    $$ = k. \frac {V^{-ฮณ+1}}{-ฮณ+1} \bigg |_{V_1}^{V_2} = \frac {k}{1-ฮณ}(V_2^{-ฮณ+1}-V_1^{-ฮณ+1})$$
    But, $ P_1V_1^ฮณ =P_2V_2^ฮณ=k $
    Hence, $ W = \frac {kV_2^{-ฮณ+2}-kV_2^{-ฮณ+2}}{1-ฮณ}=\frac {P_2V^ฮณ_2V_2^{-ฮณ+2}-P_1V_1^ฮณ.V_1^{-ฮณ+2}}{1-ฮณ} $
    $$ = \frac {P_2V_2-P_1V_1}{1-ฮณ} $$
    Using perfect gas eqaution,PV=ฮผRT,we get
    $$ W = \frac {ฮผR(T_2-T_1)}{1-ฮณ} $$
    Thus the work done during an adiabatic process is given by
    $$ W = \frac {P_2V_2-P_1V_1}{1-ฮณ} \space or \space W = \frac {ฮผR(T_2-T_1)}{1-ฮณ}= \frac {ฮผR(T_2-T_1)}{ฮณ-1}โ€ฆโ€ฆ(12.16)$$
Note box:
From the above equations, we will find that, if work is done by the gas in an adiabatic process (W > 0), from Equation (12.16),$T_2< T_1$. On the other hand, if work is done on the gas (W < 0), we get $T_2> T_1$ that is, the temperature of the gas rises.

Isochoric process

Definition box:
An isochoric process is the process in which volume is constant.
  • No work is done on or by the gas.
  • From Equation (12.1), ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + ฮ”W, we will find that the heat absorbed by the gas goes entirely to change its internal energy and its temperature, without change in volume.
Note box:
The change in temperature for a given amount of heat is determined by the specific heat of the gas at constant volume.

Isobaric process

Definition box:
Isobaric process: The process is which pressure is fixed is called an isobaric process.
  • Work done by the gas is,
    $$ W = P (V_2 โ€“ V_1) = ฮผ R (T_2 โ€“ T_1) โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ (12.17)$$
  • Since temperature changes, so does internal energy.
  • The heat absorbed goes partly to increase internal energy and partly to do work.
Note box:
The change in temperature for a given amount of heat is determined by the specific heat of the gas at constant pressure.

Cyclic process

Definition box:
Cyclic process: Cyclic process is the process in which, the system returns to its initial state.
  • Since internal energy is a state variable, ฮ”U = 0 for a cyclic process. From Equation (12.1), ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + ฮ”W, we find that, the total heat absorbed equals the work done by the system.

Questions for section 12.8:

  1. Describe under what conditions of pressure and temperature does the non-equilibrium state come into play? Also give two examples where the system goes through non equilibrium states.
  2. What is Quasi-static process? How is it achieved?
  3. What is isothermal process? Obtain the expression for work done for the same.
  4. What are isobaric and isochoric process?
  5. When do you call a process adiabatic? Obtain the expression for work done for the same.
  6. Define cyclic process.

12.9 Heat Engines

Definition box:
Heat engine: Heat engine is a device by which a system is made to undergo a cyclic process that results in conversion of heat to work. It can also be defined as the device that converts heat energy into mechanical energy

Working of the device:

(1) It consists of a working substanceโ€“the system. For example, a mixture of fuel vapour and air in a gasoline engine, or, diesel engine or, steam in a steam engine, are the working substances.

(2) The working substance goes through a cycle consisting of several processes;

In some of these processes, the substance absorbs a total amount of heat, $Q_1$ from an external reservoir at some high temperature, $T_1$.In some other processes of the cycle, the working substance releases a total amount of heat $Q_2$ to an external reservoir at some lower temperature $T_2$.

(3) The work done (W) by the system in a cycle is transferred to the immediate environment, via some arrangement. For instance, the working substance in a cylinder with a moving piston transfers mechanical energy to the wheels of a vehicle via, a shaft.

(4) The cycle is repeated again and again to get useful work for some purpose.

The basic features of a heat engine are schematically represented in Figure 12.9.

Figure 12.9 Schematic representation of a heat engine. The engine takes heat $Q_1$ from a hot reservoir at temperature $T_1$ , releases heat $Q_2$ to a cold reservoir at temperature $T_2$ and delivers work W to the surroundings.

We will now define the efficiency of a heat engine since the basic principles of thermodynamics is rooted in the working of a heat engine.

  • The efficiency (ฮท) of a heat engine is defined by:
    $$ ฮท= \frac {W}{Q_1} โ€ฆโ€ฆโ€ฆ (12.18) $$
    Where, $Q_1$ is the heat input, that is, the heat absorbed by the system in one complete cycle and W is the work done on the environment in a cycle.
  • In a cycle, a certain amount of heat, $Q_2$ may also be rejected to the environment. Then, according to the First Law of Thermodynamics(ฮ”Q = ฮ”U + ฮ”W),over one complete cycle,
    $$ W =Q_1-Q_2 โ€ฆโ€ฆ(12.19) $$
    i.e.,
    $$ ฮท= 1 -\frac {Q_2}{Q_1} โ€ฆโ€ฆ.(12.20)$$
Note box:
1. For $Q_2$ = 0, ฮท = 1, that is, the engine will have 100% efficiency in converting heat into work.
2. In real, such an ideal engine with ฮท = 1 is never possible, even if we can eliminate various kinds of losses associated with actual heat engines.
(We shall study in section 12.11 that, there is a fundamental limit on the efficiency of a heat engine set by an independent principle of nature formulated as the Second Law of Thermodynamics.) 

There are two ways in which heat is converted into work, depending on the type of the engine;

1. The system (say a gas or a mixture of gases) is heated by an external furnace as in a steam engine

2. The system is heated internally by an exothermic chemical reaction as in an internal combustion engine.

The various steps involved in a cycle differ from one engine to another. Thus, in the coming sections we will, for the purpose of general analysis, arrive at a common idea of a heat engine as having the following essential ingredients;

Questions for section 12.9:

  1. What is a heat engine? Describe its working, step-by-step.
  2. Define the efficiency of a heat engine.
  3. State the two ways in which heat is converted into work, depending on the type of the engine, mentioning the two types of engines.

12.10 Refrigerators and Heat Pumps

Principle behind the working of Refrigerator:

  • A refrigerator is the reverse of a heat engine. Here, the working substance extracts heat, $Q_2$ from the cold reservoir (sink or freezer) which is at a lower temperature, $T_2$.
  • Some external work, W is done on the cold reservoir and heat $Q_1$ is released to the hot reservoir at temperature $T_1$ (as shown in Figure 12.10 below).
Figure 12.10 Schematic representation of a refrigerator or a heat pump, the reverse of a heat engine.

Working of a refrigerator and a heat pump:

  • A heat pump is the same as a refrigerator. Their purposes of use however, are different. If the purpose is to cool a portion of space, like the inside of a chamber, and higher temperature reservoir is surrounding, we call the device a refrigerator; if the idea is to pump heat into a portion of space, say, to heat the room in a building when the outside environment is cold, the device is called a heat pump.
  • In a refrigerator, the working substance (usually, in gaseous form) goes through the following steps:
    (a) Sudden expansion of the gas from high to low pressure (as volume of the gas increases); thus, cools it and converts it into a vapour-liquid mixture,
    (b) Absorption of heat by the cold fluid (so obtained in the previous step) from the region to be cooled, converting it into vapour form again,
    (c) Next, heating up of the vapour due to external work done on the system,
    (d) Then, release of heat by the vapour to the surroundings, bringing it to the initial state and completing the cycle.
    The coefficient of performance (ฮฑ) of a refrigerator is given by
    $$ ฮฑ = \frac {Amount \space of \space heat \space adsorbed}{work \space done}=\frac {Q_2}{W} โ€ฆ.(12.21)$$
    $$ ฮฑ=\frac {Q_2}{Q_1-Q_2} โ€ฆ.(12.22)$$
    or
    $ ฮฑ = \frac {1}{\frac {Q_1}{Q_2}-1}$;from Carnot’s cycle,we know that $ \frac {Q_1}{Q_2} = \frac {T_1}{T_2}$
    $$ ฮฑ= \frac {1}{\frac {T_1}{T_2}-1} = \frac {T_2}{T_1-T_2}$$
Note box: In a heat engine, heat cannot be fully converted to work; likewise, a refrigerator cannot work without some external work done on the system, that is, the coefficient of performance in Equation (12.21) cannot be infinite.
Story:
Pioneers of Thermodynamics
Lord Kelvin (William Thomson) (1824-1907), born in Belfast, Ireland, is among the foremost British scientists of the nineteenth century. Thomson played a key role in the development of the law of conservation of energy suggested by the work of James Joule (1818-1889), Julius Mayer (1814-1878) and Hermann Helmholtz (1821-1894).

He collaborated with Joule on the so-called Joule-Thomson effect: cooling of a gas when it expands into vacuum. He introduced the notion of the absolute zero of temperature and proposed the absolute temperature scale, now called the Kelvin scale in his honour. From the work of Sadi Carnot (1796-1832), Thomson arrived at a form of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. Thomson was a versatile physicist, with notable contributions to electromagnetic theory and hydrodynamics.  

Rudolf Clausius (1822-1888), born in Poland, is generally regarded as the discoverer of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. Based on the work of Carnot and Thomson, Clausius arrived at the important notion of entropy that led him to a fundamental version of the Second Law of Thermodynamics that states that the entropy of an isolated system can never decrease. Clausius also worked on the kinetic theory of gases and obtained the first reliable estimates of molecular size, speed and mean free path.

Questions for section 12.10:

  1. What is the principle behind the working of a refrigerator? Also describe the working.
  2. How does a heat pump and refrigerator differ? 3. Give the expression for coefficient of performance.

12.11 Second Law of Thermodynamics

The Second Law of Thermodynamics gives a fundamental limitation to the efficiency of a heat engine and the co-efficient of performance of a refrigerator.

In simple terms, it says that efficiency of a heat engine can never be unity.

In case of the heat engine, according to Equation (12.20): $ ฮท= 1 -\frac {Q_2}{Q_1} $it is clear that, the heat released to the cold reservoir can never be made zero.

  • For a refrigerator, the Second Law says that the co-efficient of performance can never be infinite since, according to Equation (12.21), the external work (W) can never be zero.
    Thus, the following two statements, one due to Kelvin and Planck denying the possibility of a perfect heat engine, and another due to Clausius denying the possibility of a perfect refrigerator or heat pump, are a concise summary of the observations made above,
    (They can be synonymously used as the Second Law of Thermodynamics.)

Kelvin-Planck statement
โ€œNo process is possible whose sole result is the absorption of heat from a reservoir and the complete conversion of the heat into work.โ€
In other words, it is impossible to obtain a continuous supply of work from a body by cooling it to a temperature below the lowest of its surroundings.

Clausiusโ€™ statement

โ€œNo process is possible whose sole result is the transfer of heat from a colder object to a hotter object.โ€

In other words, it is impossible for a self-acting machine, unaided by any external agency, to transfer heat from a body at lower temperature to a body at a higher temperature.

Note box: It can be proved that the two statements above are completely equivalent.

12.12 Reversible and Irreversible Processes

Reversible process:

  • Reversible process is the process which can be made to proceed in two opposite directions with same effort in both directions, so that the system and the surroundings pass through exactly the same intermediate states as in the direct process (or the forward process).
  • The figure below shows p-V diagram for a reversible process from initial, i to final state, f and back.
Figure 12.11
  • As observed, the curve representing direct process and that representing reverse process overlap each other. Thus, we can infer in such a case that the total work done in bringing the system back to the initial state is zero.
Example box:
1. A process is reversible only if it is quasi-static (system in equilibrium with the surroundings at every stage) and there are no dissipative effects. For example, a quasi-static isothermal expansion of an ideal gas in a cylinder fitted with a frictionless movable piston is a reversible process.
2. Conversion of ice to water and water to ice, under ideal conditions.

Irreversible process:

  • Irreversible process is a process which cannot be made to proceed in the reverse direction with the same ease and the system does not pass through the same intermediate states in the direct and reverse processes.
  • An irreversible process always involves a loss of energy. This energy loss is represented by the area of the loop that will be obtained in the p-V diagram.
Example box:  
1. A body moving on a rough surface from one point to another.
2. The base of a vessel kept in the oven gets heated more than the other parts. When the vessel is removed, heat is transferred from the base to the other parts, finally bringing the vessel to a uniform temperature (which in due course cools to the temperature of the surroundings).The process cannot be reversed; that is, a part of the vessel will not get cooler by itself and warm up the base. It will violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics, if it did.
3. The free expansion of a gas is irreversible.
4. The combustion reaction of a mixture of petrol and air ignited by a spark cannot be reversed.
5. Cooking gas leaking from a gas cylinder in the kitchen diffuses to the entire room. The diffusion process will not spontaneously reverse and bring the gas back to the cylinder.
6. The stirring of a liquid in thermal contact with a reservoir will convert the work done into heat, increasing the internal energy of the reservoir. The process cannot be reversed exactly; otherwise it would amount to conversion of heat entirely into work, violating the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Irreversibility is a rule rather an exception in nature!

Questions from section 12.11 and 12.12:

  1. State the second law of thermodynamics with regard to: a) efficiency of heat engine b) co-efficient of performance of a refrigerator. Also state the laws by Kelvin-Planck and Clausius along these lines.
  2. Define and describe reversible process with relevant graph. Comment on the work done.
  3. Give two examples for a reversible process.
  4. Briefly describe an Irreversible process. Give three examples.

12.13 Carnot Engine

A heat engine essentially consists of three parts:

  1. Source: Temperature of the source will be a constant. Source can supply any amount of heat at this constant temperature. The source possesses infinite thermal energy.
  2. Working substance: It is an enclosed thermodynamic system which can do work.
  3. Sink: A sink can absorb any amount of heat while maintaining its temperature at constant level. Temperature of the sink is less than the temperature of the source. It is also of infinite thermal capacity.
  4. Insulator: Insulator is used to cover the entire base of the container. This ensures the complete thermal isolation of the working substance

Working of Carnot engine:

Carnot cycle: The working substance of the Carnot engine is taken through a cycle of operations known as the Carnot cycle. In this, all the processes are quasi-static. That is, at any stage, the deviation from equilibrium is very small.

Figure 12.12

$\mu =$ – Number of moles of gas

$\gamma =$ – Specific heat ratioโ€”Ratio of heat capacity at constant pressure $(C_p)$ to heat capacity at constant volume ($C_v$)

  • Step 1: Isothermal expansion (curve AB):
    The cylinder with the gas having pressure, $P_1$, volume,$V_1$ and temperature, $T_1$ is allowed to expand slowly. The temperature tends to decrease. But it is maintained constant at $T_1$ by absorbing heat from the source. The expansion is isothermal. Let the amount of heat absorbed from the source be $Q_1$. Let the pressure and volume change to $P_2$ and $V_2$.
    For an isothermal process,
    dQ= dW
    Hence ,$Q_1=W_1= \int_{V_1}^{V_2} PdV = ฮผRT_1 \space ln \big( \frac {V_2}{V_1} \big) $ ,or Work done by the gas = area ABGEA
    Work done by the gas = Area ABGEA
  • Step 2: Adiabatic Expansion (Curve BC):
    The cylinder is placed on the non-conducting stand and the gas is allowed to expand adiabatically until its temperature falls to $T_2$K. Let the pressure and volume $P_2$ and $V_2$ change to $P_3$ and $V_3$.
    The work done during the expansion is $ W_2 = \int_{V_2}^{V_3} PdV = \frac {ฮผR}{ ฮณ-1} (T_1-T_2) โ€ฆ.(12.24)$
    Work done by the gas = Area BCHGB
  • Step 3: Isothermal Compression (Curve CD):
    In order to make the gas recover its capacity for doing work, it should be brought to the original condition. This is done in next two steps.
    The cylinder is placed on the sink at temperature $T_2$. The gas is compressed slowly. The temperature tends to increase; but is maintained constant at $T_2$ by rejecting heat to sink. The compression is isothermal. Let the amount of heat rejected to the sink be $Q_2$. Let the pressure and volume: $P_3$ and $V_3$ change to $P_4$ and $V_4$. For an isothermal process,
    dQ= dW
    Hence, $ -Q_2=W_3 = \int_{V_3}^{V_4} PdV = ฮผRT_2 \space ln \bigg( \frac {V_4}{V_3} \bigg) = – ฮผRT_2 \space ln \bigg( \frac {V_3}{V_4} \bigg) \hspace{10mm} (note \space that \space V_4 < V_3) โ€ฆ..(12.25)$
    $$ |W_3| = ฮผRT_2 \space ln \bigg( \frac {V_3}{V_4} \bigg) \space or , \space Work \space done \space on \space the \space gas = area \space CDFHC โ€ฆ..(12.26)$$
  • Step 4: Adiabatic Compression (curve DA):
    The cylinder is placed on the conducting stand and the gas is compressed adiabatically till pressure and volume $P_4$ and $V_4$ increase to $P_1$ and $V_1$ and the temperature increases to $T_1$ K. The work done during the compression is,
    $$ W_4 = \int_{V_4}^{V_1} PdV = \frac {ฮผR}{ ฮณ-1} (T_2-T_1) =- \frac {R}{ฮณ-1}(T_1-T_2)$$
    $$ |W_4| = \frac {ฮผR}{ฮณ-1} \space(T_1-T_2) \space or , \space Work \space done \space on \space the \space gas = area \space BCHGBโ€ฆ..(12.26)$$
    Work done on the gas is = Area BCHGB
  • Now, the conditions are the same as it was initially (we are now at point A in the indicator diagram) and the cycle can be repeated.
  • The net heat absorbed by the gas is = Q1โ€“ Q2
  • The net work done by the gas = $W_1+W_2-|W_3| -|W_4| = W_1- W_3$; (since, $W_2=|W_4|$)
    $$ = ฮผ RT_1 \space ln \bigg( \frac {V_2}{V_1} \bigg) – ฮผ RT_2 \space ln \bigg( \frac {V_3}{V_4} \bigg) โ€ฆ.(12.27) $$
    Or, the net work done by the gas per cycle = area ABCD
  • By first law, for a cyclic process, dQ= dW.
  • Thus, $Q_1-Q_2= W_1-|W_3|$= area ABCD = the area enclosed.

Efficiency of Carnotโ€™s heat engine

Definition box:
The efficiency of heat engine is defined as the ratio of amount of heat converted into mechanical work to the amount of heat absorbed from the source.

, $ฮท= \frac {The \space amount \space of \space heat \space converted \space to \space work}{The \space amount \space of \space heat \space absorbed}$

In the Carnotโ€™s heat engine, heat $Q_1$ is drawn from the source. Out of this, $Q_2$ is rejected to the sink. The remaining $Q_1-Q_2$ is converted into mechanical work.

Thus,
$ Thus,ฮท = \frac {Q_1-Q_2}{Q_1} =1- \frac {Q_2}{Q_1} โ€ฆ.(1)$

But,$Q_1=RT_1 \space ln \big( \frac {V_2}{V_1} \big) $ nad $Q_2=RT_2 \space ln \big( \frac {V_3}{V_4} \big) $

Therefore, $\frac {Q_2}{Q_1} = \frac { T_2 \space ln \big( \frac {V_3}{V_4} \big) }{T_1 \space ln \big( \frac {V_2}{V_1} \big) } โ€ฆ.(12.28)$

For the $2^{nd}$ step ,we have the adiabatic equation,$T_1V_2^{ฮณ-1}=T_2V_3^{ฮณ-1},or,\frac {T_2}{T_1}=\bigg( \frac {V_2}{V_3} \bigg)^{ฮณ-1} $

For the $4^{th}$ step ,we have the adiabatic equation,$T_2V_4^{ฮณ-1}=T_1V_1^{ฮณ-1},or,\frac {T_2}{T_1}=\bigg( \frac {V_1}{V_4} \bigg)^{ฮณ-1} $

Thus ,$\frac {T_2}{T_1}=\bigg( \frac {V_2}{V_3} \bigg)^{ฮณ-1}=\bigg( \frac {V_1}{V_4} \bigg)^{ฮณ-1} \space or,\bigg( \frac {V_2}{V_3} \bigg)=\bigg( \frac {V_1}{V_4} \bigg)$

Substituting in eq(2),we get , $ \frac {Q_2}{Q_1}=\frac {T_2}{T_1}$

Hence, by eq(1) we get,Efficiency $ ฮท=1- \frac {Q_2}{Q_1}=1-\frac {T_2}{T_1}$

  • Thus, efficiency of the Carnotโ€™s engine depends only on the temperature of the source and the sink.
  • $\eta $ increases as $T_1$ increases and $T_2$ decreases.
  • $\eta = 1,$ when the temperature of sink, $T_2$= 0. This concept forms basis for the definition of absolute zero temperature.
Note box:
Absolute zero of temperature can be defined as that temperature of the sink for which the efficiency of the Carnotโ€™s engine is 100%.

Carnotโ€™s Theorem

Statement: Working between two given temperatures $T_1$ and $T_2$ of the hot and cold reservoirs respectively, no engine can be more efficient than a reversible Carnot Engine.

Figure 12.12 An irreversible engine (I) coupled to a reversible refrigerator (R). If W โ€ฒ > W, this would amount to extraction of heat Wโ€ฒ โ€“ W from the sink and its full conversion to work, in contradiction with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Proof:

  • Referring figure, 12.22 above, let R and I represent two heat engines working between a source at a temperature, T1 and sink at a temperature, T2. Let R be reversible and I be irreversible. Let their efficiencies be $n_R$ and $n_I$ respectively.
  • Let R and I be coupled, such that I acts as a heat engine and R act as a refrigerator. Let I absorb heat Q from the source, deliver work, W and release the remaining heat (Q-W) to the sink. Let R absorb heat Qโ€™ from the sink and release heat Q to the source when work, Wโ€™ is done on working substance. Then,
    Qโ€™ = Q – Wโ€™
  • Let us assume that, $n_I > n_R$ .
    That is, Work done by I> Work done on R. So, W>Wโ€™
    Then, Q – Wโ€™ > Q โ€“ W
    That is, Heat absorbed by R from the sink > Heat released by I to the sink
  • Therefore, the net amount of heat absorbed by the coupled engine from the sink = Q – Wโ€™ โ€“ Q + W = W โ€“ Wโ€™.
  • Thus, the coupled engine draws heat W- Wโ€™ from the sink at lower temperature, $T_2$ and transfers it completely to the source at a higher temperature, $T_1$ without the aid of an external agency. This violates the second law of thermodynamics. Hence the assumption that $n_I > n_R$ is wrong.
  • Hence, we can say that no engine can have efficiency greater than that of Carnotโ€™s engine.

Questions for section 12.13:

  1. Describe briefly, the four essential parts of a heat engine.
  2. Describe the working of a Carnotโ€™s heat engine explaining the various cycles involved in detail. Include all necessary equations and diagrams at each stage.
  3. Give the expression for efficiency of a heat engine.
  4. Define absolute zero of temperature with respect to Carnotโ€™s engine.
  5. State and prove Carnotโ€™s theorem with the relevant figure.