Six students A, B, C, D, E and F appeared in several tests. Either C or F scores the highest. Whenever C scores the highest, then E scores the least. Whenever F scores the highest, B scores the least. In all the tests they got different marks; D scores higher than A, but they are close competitors; A scores higher than B; C scores higher than A.
Q. If F stands second in the ranking, then the position of B is:
To solve this problem, let’s analyze each condition step-by-step and use them to infer the positions of each student in the ranking.
Given Information and Analysis
1. Either C or F scores the highest.
This means that in every test, the top scorer will be either C or F.
2. Whenever C scores the highest, then E scores the least.
So, if C is ranked 1st, then E will be ranked last (6th).
3. Whenever F scores the highest, B scores the least.
So, if F is ranked 1st, then B will be ranked last (6th).
4. All students scored different marks.
This implies there are no ties in the rankings.
5. D scores higher than A, but they are close competitors.
Since D and A are close competitors, their ranks should be adjacent, with D ranked just above A.
6. A scores higher than B.
This means A’s position will be above B in the ranking.
7. C scores higher than A.
So, C must be ranked above A as well.
8. F is ranked second.
We are given that F stands second in the ranking, so we will use this information to determine the possible positions of other students.
Step-by-Step Deduction
Since we know that F is ranked second, we can deduce the following based on each condition:
1. If F is ranked second, then C must be ranked first (because either C or F scores the highest, and F cannot be first if it is in second place).
Therefore:
2. Since C is ranked first, E must be ranked lastย (6th), based on the condition that if C scores the highest, E scores the least.
Therefore:
3. Now we have determined the positions of C (1st), F (2nd), and E (6th). The remaining students to be placed are A, B, and D.
4. A scores higher than B.
This means B cannot be 3rd, as A must be ranked above B.
5. D scores higher than A, and they are close competitors.
Since D and A are close competitors, they must be in adjacent positions, with D ranked above A. The only available consecutive positions for D and A that satisfy this condition are 3rd and 4th.
Therefore:
6. This leaves only the 5th position for B.
Since A is 4th, and B scores lower than A, B must be in the 5th position.
Final Rankings
Based on the deductions above, the ranking order is:
- C: 1st
- F: 2nd
- D: 3rd
- A: 4th
- B: 5th
- E: 6th
Conclusion
The correct answer is (c) Fifth, as B is in the 5th position.